Showing posts with label Social Issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Social Issues. Show all posts

July 28, 2022

Wisconsin Post-COVID Homeschool Data

It's common knowledge by now that homeschooling (actual homeschooling, not virtual public schooling or "distance learning") exploded in the first full "school year" following the March 2020 nationwide school closures caused by COVID-19 hysteria. Even the US Census Bureau admitted it, indicating that homeschooling increased from a pre-pandemic average of about 3% across the country to over 11% in Fall 2020 and a whopping 19.5% (almost one in five school-aged kids!) by Spring 2021. 

Many predicted the numbers would fall right back to pre-pandemic levels by Fall 2021, as government schools "got back to normal." And, of course, some parents did send their kids back into the system. But the big surprise was that most who pulled their kids out for homeschooling between March 2020 and Spring 2021 continued to keep their children home during the 2021-22 "school year," mainly because they had discovered the huge benefits of private home-based education and had lost any interest in returning their children to the factory-style system. 

I've read several articles to this effect over the past few months, heartened that parents' eyes have been opened and encouraged at their resolve to stay the course. And my colleague at The Homeschool Loft and I have experienced this anecdotally in our community as we've met with current and prospective homeschooling parents. 

But I was very curious about the numbers throughout Wisconsin, where I live, and finally got a look at the belatedly-released data this week. 

Despite the long history of homeschooling here - ours was among the first, in 1984, to re-legalize the practice in the modern era - and our incredibly favorable homeschool law, Wisconsin's homeschool numbers have always lagged behind those of many other states. We finally hit 2% of the school-aged population in Fall 2001, and the percentage hovered a little above or below that mark (representing anywhere from about 18,000 to a little over 21,000 children in any given year) all the way up until its pre-pandemic high, in Fall 2019, of 2.17%. 

Though nowhere near the national average during 2020-21, Wisconsin did see a huge homeschool spike in Fall 2020, when the percentage went from 2.17% all the way up to 3.25, a greater than 47% increase! In raw numbers, that means the state went from having 21,644 homeschooled children in Fall 2019 to an impressive 31,878 in Fall 2020. 

But, of course, the big test of the relative commitment level of the Badger state's crop of COVID-inspired homeschoolers is seen in Fall 2021 enrollment data. And the great news - for those of us who wish to inspire all parents to take direct personal responsibility for their children's education - is that Wisconsin reflected national trends in that vein, showing only a slight decrease in homeschool numbers. Specifically, the percentage of homeschooled kids in Wisconsin in Fall 2021 was 3% (29,402 kids), which was still a 36% increase from the state's pre-COVID numbers. 

Interestingly, it seems clear that those who left homeschooling in Fall 2021 did not return to government schools. In fact, government school enrollment decreased by over 25,000 students between Fall 2019 and Fall 2020 and by another 792 in Fall 2021. But enrollment in private schools increased by 2,867 kids between Fall 2020 and Fall 2021, which is almost the exact same number of children (2,476) who left homeschooling during that timeframe. In other words, homeschooling is holding quite steady in record-high numbers post-COVID, and those who only tried homeschooling for one year then moved on to private schools rather than returning their kids to public ones.

In my opinion, this is wonderful news for Wisconsin, and I hope homeschooling numbers hold firm or even increase again this coming fall. Children everywhere, including in my home state, deserve the best education possible, which (contrary to stereotype) can really only happen when it is customized to each child's unique, individual needs. Quite apart from (illogical) school COVID policies and the (very disturbing) highly-politicized nature of government schooling these days, that's what it comes down to. And the best people to customize an education for a child are those who know him best and love him most - i.e., his parents - when they enjoy true academic freedom as afforded to them in homeschooling.

*****
PhotoCredit: WorldAtlas

August 29, 2020

Supposed to . . . Instead . . .

Whatever your position on the nature of 2020's "coronavirus scare," there's no doubt that it has significantly disrupted all of our lives over the last six months or so - and may continue to do so for some time to come.

I already knew in January that this year would challenge me simply because it would mark the end of my journey as a homeschool mom; I even wrote about my "year of lasts" in June 2019. But, of course, I had no idea that so many milestones and important family events would end up being lost entirely or manifesting so very differently than I'd originally anticipated - and I never imagined that so many things would be turned upside down, in large measure because of other people's reactions to a microscopic pathogen.

To be sure, our challenges haven't (thank God) been catastrophic; in fact, some (the homeschool spring formal and our graduation party in particular) may have turned out to be better than originally intended. But we have experienced real stress over the chaos of the last few months, and our lives going into this fall do look very different from what we'd envisioned at the beginning of 2020. So as I stand on the precipice of my first autumn as a "retired" homeschool mom, I thought it worth recounting what was supposed to have happened over the last several months versus what actually occurred instead.
*****

The year was moving along pretty much as anticipated through January and February and into March. But then...

Rachel was supposed to play her 11-page Class A piano piece - which she'd begun practicing in August 2019 - at the district music festival on March 13. If she'd played well, she would have earned her first-ever berth at the state festival in May.
Instead, the festival was cancelled just hours before she was slated to play. 
Attempting a video lesson shortly after the festival was cancelled

Rachel was supposed to continue taking on more and more shifts at her job as a YMCA lifeguard, both to earn and save money for college and to transition more and more into adult life.
Instead, she was furloughed starting on March 16, and has yet to be called back for a single shift even though the Y reopened in June. Rather than continue to wait around for shifts that might never come, she finally opted in July to open her own business - Girl Friday - through which she does various odd jobs (cleaning, babysitting, painting, cat-sitting, gardening, etc.) by request.
Working her first Girl Friday gig

Rachel was supposed to continue tutoring through our city's literacy council, which she'd done since October 2018.
Instead, she hasn't seen her student since March and doesn't know if they will ever reconnect. 

Rachel was supposed to play her Class A solo and one other piece at her senior piano recital in April.
Instead, her teacher was forced to postpone and eventually cancel the recital.

The girls were supposed to sing in their final homeschool choir concert at the end of April - a performance of pieces from Broadway's Anastasia in which Abbie had a featured role and Rachel would serve as one of the narrators.
Instead, the director was forced to postpone and eventually cancel the concert.
Fall 2019 choir rehearsal

I was supposed to coordinate the 20th annual spring formal for our homeschool group in April. We expected 75 or more teens, which would have been the group's largest event of its kind.
Instead, I first had to postpone and then cancel entirely. A small group of 20 teens did participate in an alternate event at the end of May that turned out to be special in its own right, so my girls did at least get a senior prom of sorts.
Speakeasy Spring Formal

I was supposed to coordinate the June 6 graduation ceremony for our homeschool group. Twenty-five teens from 23 families would have participated, making it the group's largest-ever ceremony.
Instead, circumstances led several families to drop out by early May, our original venue cancelled on us just a couple weeks before the ceremony date, and we scrambled to find a new location. The new venue had a much lower capacity so we had to limit attendance and lost a few more families in the process. We still had a beautiful ceremony - Abbie was part of the special music team, and Rachel finally got to play her solo as part of the ceremony's prelude music! - but we ended up with just 13 graduates representing 12 families. 

We were supposed to have our graduation party - a joint celebration with some dear friends whose daughter also graduated with our homeschool group - at our favorite park (where the girls played all the time when they were little) a few blocks from our home.
Instead, city policies made it impossible to hold the event as we'd envisioned it, so we moved the party - rather at the last minute - to our friends' family farm an hour from town. 

Abbie was supposed to be living at home after graduation, working and going to college while we planned her wedding for sometime in Spring 2021.
Instead - fueled at least in part by virus-related lockdown measures - Abbie and her love, Gabriel, chose to elope on May 13! She moved in with him on June 14, and we held a reception for them on July 18. I'm still adjusting to her not living here anymore. 

Rachel was supposed to volunteer at Lake Lundgren Bible Camp for several week-long camps throughout the summer.
Instead, LLBC first delayed the start of camp and then cancelled everything for the entire summer. Rachel did make a couple of day-trips to help out with maintenance work, but it was nothing like what she'd anticipated.

In mid-August, Abbie was supposed to start full-time in the Administrative Professional program at the local community college.
Instead, she changed jobs - taking a full-time assistant teacher position (which she loves) at a local Montessori preschool - a couple of weeks before the semester started, and decided to go part-time at the college. But then, less than two weeks into the semester, she chose to switch to the Early Childhood Education program, which necessitated dropping her Admin Prof classes and applying to the new program. Schedule-permitting, she may start part-time EC classes in January.

Our church was supposed to mark 50 years of ministry in September with a weekend-long celebration. Many with ties to the church over the years planned to travel from near and far to join us.
Instead, the event has been postponed until September 2021...so a 50th anniversary celebration has to wait for acknowledgement until the church's fifty-first year.

Rachel was supposed to leave today - August 29 - to begin her studies at a missions-oriented Bible college that she'd had in mind to attend for at least two years - as her first step toward serving in Japan.
Instead, the school's last-minute adoption of a draconian, inflexible mask policy led Rachel to drop out in protest less than two weeks before she was slated to begin. We're very proud of the stance she's taken even as we ache that her long-held plans have been unjustly upended. We're now helping her to recalibrate her thoughts and plans, which likely include ramping up her Girl Friday services, working and volunteering in other capacities, and (possibly) taking a class or two through the local community college. 
Her "at-home dorm room"
Add to this what has been going on in my husband's life - he's been working from home, ensconced in his basement office since March 16, trying to be a corporate trainer via Zoom for a company with an international reach (and with no hope of returning to the office until "at least" January 2021); he's got a missions-mobilizing ministry but cannot actually mobilize any current missions teams; his ministry's annual fundraising golf outing was cancelled because of virus-related policies at the venue - and all I can really say is that this has been a lot to digest.

Though I've grown in flexibility over the years, the "Rou-Tina" part of my personality bristles over the fact that my routine has been out of whack for almost six months - with no end in sight. And my inner Momma Bear hates that the girls - especially Rachel - have lost so much that should have been normal in their senior year and launching into young adult life.

Of course, I do see that it's not all bad. I love my new son-in-law even though I didn't expect him to bear that title until next year; I know he's the man God has always destined for Abbie. I also believe that whatever God is doing in His redirection of Rachel's life right now, it will be good; she stood up to the college with godly motivation so He will bring beauty from what might seem like ashes at the moment. And I'm grateful that our lives have not been devastated by job loss and related problems that are hurting so many others.

So I'm not complaining even if it might seem that I am. It's just interesting thinking about the "supposed to" versus the "instead." I don't know how our current circumstances - in the lives of my family members or society at large - will play out going forward...or what lessons we're all supposed to (!) glean from this. Time will tell. In the meantime, I'm just really, really glad I know Jeremiah 29:11!

I know the plans I have for you, declares the LORD,
plans to prosper you and not to harm you, to give you a future and a hope.

August 11, 2020

A Plea to New Homeschoolers

Many thousands of parents have responded to the coronavirus situation as it affects conventional schools - both public and private - by choosing to leave the system and move to private, independent, home-based education (i.e., homeschooling). If you are one of those new homeschoolers - coming into homeschooling for the short- or long-term - know that we veterans will welcome and try to help you. But, in return, we ask that you keep a few very important points in mind:
1. If you are using a public school's virus-related distance learning or a virtual/charter public school, you are not homeschooling (from a legal perspective) even though your kids are at home. That's not a value judgment, just a legal reality. Actual homeschoolers operate under a different set of laws, and it's imperative to understand, acknowledge, and respect the distinctions. For a complete analysis of what is and is not homeschooling, check out this article; 
2. Current state homeschool laws have been in place for 25+ years. Modern homeschool pioneers fought hard for the freedoms inherent in those laws - some even went to jail - and bureaucrats are regularly on the lookout even to this day for ways to take that freedom away. Therefore, it's incumbent on every new homeschooler to know the law in your state and abide by it. You will have great freedom as a homeschooler - but with freedom comes the responsibility to make sure it continues for others down the line. If you knowingly flout the homeschool law just because you're new to the party and don't like the rules, you risk everyone's freedom going forward. Please don't do it; 
3. One distinct feature of homeschooling is that homeschool parents do not receive taxpayer funds or other government-sponsored stipends. We pay for our kids' resources on our own (yes, even as we're also forced to pay taxes for public schools). That doesn't seem fair and perhaps it's not - but self-funding is a hallmark of homeschooling. And the reward for using only our own money is freedom (i.e., no one has the right to say how we can or can't use our own money). Veteran homeschoolers fought long and hard to obtain and keep that freedom too. So do not come in and try to get that changed. If you want government funding, you need to go with distance learning or virtual/charter public schooling, not homeschooling; 
4. There are literally thousands of homeschool curriculum resource providers out there - over 4,800, to be precise...all of which you can see on The Homeschool Resource Roadmap (HERE for alphabetical lists and HERE if you want to start choosing what to use for your kids). And there is great diversity amongst those resources! Some will not comport with your personal/family values and you may even be "offended" by some companies' views. The answer: just don't buy that stuff. But please do not bully those who do...or talk about getting it banned (yes, that has, sadly, been happening!). There is something for every homeschooler, and it's not your job to try to control a market that has existed for almost 40 years. Spend your money as you please and don't complain about how anyone else spends theirs; 
5. The same is true for homeschool groups. If you find an existing homeschool group you don't like...move on and find a different one or start a new one yourself. It's not your job to come in and try to "reform" long-standing organizations that you don't happen to understand or like. We do truly want to help...but, as Abraham Lincoln said, "Let not him who is houseless pull down the house of another, but let him work diligently and build one for himself..."
As you begin private homeschooling, you are coming into a beautiful, rich lifestyle choice upon which our country was actually founded - and which has been vibrant in the modern era for more than 40 years. Veterans will generously show you the ropes so you can start to build your own homeschooling "house" - we'll be your biggest cheerleaders! But please understand that we won't allow the basic blueprints of the movement to be altered by "newbies." Just as you would not walk into someone's home and start knocking down walls, please respect the history and integrity of the system you're joining. If it's not for you, that's totally fine; you have other options. If you're choosing homeschooling, though, you need to accept what it is...and is not.

July 11, 2020

Look Back and Go Forth


Much to the chagrin of experienced home educators, a large percentage of the general population still seems to think that homeschooling is a new educational model or even a fad. Driven by ill-informed and/or agenda-driven media reports, they mistakenly believe homeschooling to be a novel idea taken up recently by “religious weirdos” or wealthy, entitled elites. In fact, a lot of younger and prospective homeschoolers believe the same things because it’s all they’ve ever heard, causing them to wrestle with insecurity over their interest in home education. They worry that trying something “new” and “untested” might somehow damage their children’s growth and development.

Luckily for them, the cultural misconceptions – whether accidental or deliberate – couldn’t be further from the truth.

In point of fact, home-based learning – the practice of a child’s parents serving as his primary educators in all realms of life (physical, emotional, social/relational, spiritual, and intellectual/academic) – is as old as time and spans across all geographical regions and cultures. Though outsourcing a child’s education to paid strangers (i.e., school teachers) at younger and younger ages for more and more time each day and year is the current norm in many places, things haven’t always been as they are now. In fact, institutional schooling such as we currently know it – not homeschooling – is the actual social experiment.

In America, homeschooling in one form or another was practiced by all Native tribes and was the norm among European immigrants from the Pilgrims’ initial landing in 1620 all the way through the Civil War. Where community schools occasionally popped up during this time, children attended on a voluntary basis for a very limited amount of time, typically for only a few weeks during the winter and summer seasons and only between about age eight and 14. Parents of schooled children retained tight control over what and how teachers taught, and many never sent their kids at all. Yet literacy rates and overall educational accomplishment soared all throughout the colonial era and into the nation’s first century of existence as a republic, led by parents as their children’s main educators.

However, even as Americans spread their wings of independence after the Revolution, there remained an undercurrent of “loyalist” discontent – a cadre of individuals who longed for a return to monarchy and who shared that desire with their children and grandchildren. These parents often sent their children to European boarding schools, which had adopted Prussian ideals of militaristic structure and control. This European-trained oligarchy openly longed for European-style social stratification and a means of controlling the American “masses” for their own gain.

And they seized their opportunity to do so after the Civil War. Americans were stressed by the chaos the war had caused and longed for a return to stability. The oligarchy – led by the likes of Horace Mann, John Dewey, and the Rockefellers – took advantage of this and promoted compulsory, government-sponsored schooling as a solution, promising that if all children were taught the same things in the same (managed, regulated) way, the nation could “heal.” And, when waves of immigrants from eastern and southern Europe began streaming into America near the end of the 19th century, these same “progressive” elites used people’s fear of change to advance the cause of factory-style, government-controlled schooling even further.

Some states outlawed homeschooling outright, not because it had failed children, but merely to force resistant parents to send their children to the “public” schools. In other states, home education was never officially banned. But it became so rare as more and more families defaulted (under duress) to government schooling (or parochial schools begrudgingly tolerated by the oligarchs – as long as they adopted the public-school methods) that people thought it had been criminalized and eventually gave it up.

By the 1960s, however, the fallout from a system of institutional schooling that treated children like products on an assembly line and purposely marginalized parents and their values began to manifest. Parents from all political stripes – from counter-cultural liberals to religious conservatives and many in between – became frustrated when their concerns fell on (purposely) deaf bureaucratic ears. Through the 1970s and into the ‘80s, leaders from diverse backgrounds – John Holt and Raymond S. Moore most notably among them – began advocating for parents to take back control over their children’s education and eventually created an informal alliance that promoted a return to home-based learning. Following several protracted legal battles, homeschooling was – by 1993 – once again acknowledged as a legal means of education in every state.

It’s because homeschooling was dormant (though never completely dead) for about 80 years that people feel justified in saying it is “new” and “untested.” But, of course, a practice that has existed throughout time and across cultures and then predominated for 280 years of American history before taking a relatively short, coerced hiatus is neither new nor untested. Rather, it is a time-honored approach that was asleep for a time but has now been reawakened. And even if we only consider “modern homeschooling,” that movement is at least 50 years old; it’s obviously not “new.”

We homeschoolers must embrace our movement’s long, venerable history as we go forward. Even though we look “radical” compared to the current cultural norm, we can hold our heads high if we understand that our critics are simply ignorant of true history on this subject. We’re not walking away from tried-and-true educational practices and, thus, jeopardizing our kids’ well-being. No. We’re actually walking away from a dangerous experiment gone bad. And we’re returning to a rich, family-based lifestyle of holistic learning that’s been passed down for thousands of years all around the globe in order to fully meet our responsibility as parents.

You are called to educate your children at home according to your convictions and values because you know them better and love them more than anyone else on the planet ever could. Walk in confidence with the history of the ages behind you and your best dreams and hopes for your precious children ahead. Look back and go forth.

*****
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Gaither, Milton. Homeschool: An American History. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008. 
Gatto, John Taylor. The Underground History of American Education. New York: The Oxford Village Press, 2001.
Murphy, Joseph. Homeschooling in America: Capturing and Assessing the Movement. Thousand Oaks CA: Corwin, 2012. 

March 12, 2020

Coronavirus Led Me to Homeschooling; Now What?

On March 11, 2020, coronavirus panic in the U.S. ramped up significantly - and just a day later, it was in full overdrive. As I write on the evening of March 12, there's no telling how long the hysteria will last or what its long-term ramifications will be. But what is undeniable is that - warranted or not - people are being forced to change many aspects of their normal lifestyles.

Among parents with school-aged children, no small number is dealing with the indefinite closure of their kids' schools. And "social distancing" recommendations - again, whether warranted or not - mean those children (and their parents) must remain largely at home. Some closed schools are activating online learning platforms, ostensibly requiring (though probably without long-term enforcement capabilities) that students log on and complete schoolwork virtually. However, not all schools have such capabilities - and many students do not have access to compatible devices in their homes even if schools attempt to mandate "attendance."

In response to this situation, it's entirely possible that a noticeably large number of parents may opt to entirely abandon institutional schools - public and private - and turn, instead, to home-based education, particularly private, independent homeschooling. At the risk of sounding like an "ambulance chaser," I must admit - as a sold-out homeschooler - that I see a possible increase in homeschooling families as a very positive side effect of an admittedly stressful, unfortunate turn of events. After all, parents choosing to take direct, personal responsibility for their kids' education is always a good thing, even if the impetus for doing so is something we wish would not have happened. And I hope that many parents who currently intend to homeschool only until this crisis abates will realize the beauty and benefits of home learning and continue long after school doors reopen.

I am ready to help any in my sphere of influence as they get going; contact me HERE if interested. And I call on other homeschoolers to likewise come alongside any "newbies" they might meet, in person or online.

If you are a coronavirus-driven homeschooler, let me first acknowledge that I know you're probably scared as all get-out. You may have been mulling over homeschooling before or it may never have crossed your mind. But now here you are. Your kids are home and you feel compelled to "do something" educational with them, hoping to avoid "screwing them up" in the process.

First, let me assure you that you will not hurt them. Any parent who chooses to become intentional about facilitating his or her kids' learning is perfectly equipped to do well for one simple but very powerful, double-pronged reason: you know your kids better than anyone else on the planet (yes, you do!), and you love them more than any other person ever will. That knowledge and love will motivate you to do your homework as you jump into homeschooling. And, spurred on by love, you will discover your kids' learning strengths and weaknesses, find good resources, and put in the necessary time and effort. Your homeschool "qualification" is your child's birth certificate!

Assuming you believe me, I know you're still wondering about the nuts and bolts of getting started. In fact, shelves and shelves of books have been written on the question of "how to homeschool." But you don't have time to find and read them; your kids are home now, and you've decided to jump on the homeschool bandwagon, ready or not. So let me offer a just a few "ground zero" tips to consider right now:

  1. Understand your state's homeschool law. I sincerely hope that no bureaucrats will come after well-meaning parents who decide to homeschool on the COVID-19 fly and inadvertently forget to cross some legal t or dot an i - but we can't count on them to exhibit grace and compassion even in crisis. So you need to follow your state's homeschool law from the beginning. If you do an internet search for your state's law, you'll find myriad sources - but some are more reliable than others, and it's impossible to tell at first glance which are reputable. So I recommend reaching out to an experienced homeschooler in your area - look for local homeschool groups on Facebook - to get you headed in the right direction. If you're in Wisconsin, ask me; I've even detailed various elements of the Wisconsin homeschool law HERE;
  2. I recommend that new homeschoolers take a period of time to "deschool," which I believe is critically important. However, deschooling often involves getting out and about in the community - to rebuild family relationships, give children (and parents!) time to decompress from school-style thinking, and enable a parent to begin seeing his/her kids as learners - and, sadly, the virus scare may preclude much of that for a time. But don't be discouraged. Partake in the wonderful, valuable deschooling activities that are currently possible, and save outside-the-home things for later. Deschooling activities are all educational - they can be easily categorized into school-style "subject areas" if you feel so compelled - so don't feel one ounce of guilt for spending time on them;
  3. When you feel ready to find curricula, realize that there's a plethora of options available to you - in all subject areas, for all learning styles, for kids of all ages, from multiple religious/worldview perspectives, at a wide variety of price points. If you're really interested in seeing all the possibilities, take a look at The Homeschool Resource Roadmap charts HERE ...or - if you want to avoid all connection to the common core standards - HERE. You'll be amazed - and perhaps overwhelmed - by all the options from which you have to choose...but if you're game for digging into the links, you can find something to meet the needs of each of your children;
  4. I don't pretend to know what resources are best for every child - remember that you alone are the expert on your kids - but I know that the prospect of pouring over the long Roadmap lists - or even my shorter lists of personal recommendations - can be very daunting for new homeschoolers (and for many veterans as well). So I'd like to suggest just a few (reasonably-priced, easy-to-use) basic options to consider trying for the next few months as you get your feet wet. Though you may not end up using these for the long term (homeschoolers often switch around several times in their first few years as they hone in on their kids' real needs and usually end up becoming "eclectic" - i.e., picking and choosing from different companies for different "subject areas" - along the way), all are solid and thorough such that you can feel secure in giving them a shot:

    - Christian Light Education
    - Fun-Schooling (The Thinking Tree)
    - Gather Round Homeschool
    - Homeschool Share
    - Master Books
    - Monarch (Alpha-Omega Publications)
    - Queen Homeschool Supplies
    - Robinson Self-Teaching Curriculum, The
    - Under the Home
    - Weaver (Alpha-Omega Publications)

Above all else, give yourself - and your children - grace. As with any new endeavor, beginning to homeschool means that you will face an inevitable learning curve and experience some bumps and obstacles along the way. Depending on your situation, the journey may be pretty rough at times. But the rewards - personal autonomy for yourself and your kids, freedom from the stress that accompanies institutional school schedules, deepened family relationships, the sense of accomplishment that comes from knowing you've taken direct responsibility for your kids' academic learning - make the difficulties worth it in the end. The coronavirus situation is certainly not something to celebrate...but we can and should acknowledge and embrace good things (like more families choosing to homeschool) that sprout from it.

January 31, 2020

My Feelings about National School Choice Week: It's Complicated

This past week was designated as National School Choice Week (NSCW), an event held annually in January since 2011. According to the NSCW website, the sponsoring organization "is a nonpartisan, nonpolitical, independent public awareness effort" that is "not associated with any legislative lobbying or advocacy." It "recognizes all K-12 options, including traditional public schools, public charter schools, public magnet schools, private schools, online academies, and homeschooling," and encourages supporters to hold local school choice celebrations to "raise public awareness of the different K-12 education options available to children and families while also spotlighting the benefits of school choice." The NSCW foundation reports that more than 40,000 distinct local celebrations occurred in 2019.

As an unabashed advocate of homeschooling, people have regularly asked me how I celebrate NSCW, assuming that I've been on board with the initiative since its advent. I did order a supply kit one year, though I didn't end up planning an event. The truth is that my honest answer regarding my feelings about NSCW is, "It's complicated."

On the one hand, I truly appreciate the NSCW effort that highlights a reality too few parents understand: government-sponsored, state schooling (i.e., public school) is far from the only viable educational option in this country. Non-government options actually have a long history of success - in particular, America was founded almost exclusively by homeschoolers of one sort or another - but the powerful, vociferous public school lobby has clung to its bully pulpit since the early 20th century, doing everything it can to marginalize every other option. As a result, many parents today still don't realize they have choices - but efforts such as NSCW help to dispel that myth.

I also appreciate NSCW's position of trusting "parents to make the best choices for their individual children." Indeed, I am a strong proponent of parental rights, holding unwaveringly to the view that no one other than a child's parents have a legitimate right to an opinion about how that child is educated. Loving extended family members (and, perhaps, a few very close friends) might - with a parent's express permission - offer their thoughts and ideas. But the ultimate authority for making decisions about a child's educational endeavors is in the hands of his/her parents (with the understanding - from my worldview perspective - that parents will answer to God for the choices they make). If friends and family disagree with a parent's choice, they must submit to the will of the parent and keep their mouths shut going forward. And it should go without saying that - absent a proven case of extreme neglect that results in a loss of custody - governmental bureaucrats have absolutely no right to an opinion.

Because of this, I really do agree that every parent is free to choose any educational path for his/her children - even when another parent's choice would never be my own. However, I'm uncomfortable giving full-throated support to NSCW since it does include government school options (especially traditional public schools, but also public charter schools and public magnet schools) among those it promotes. In my view, state-sponsored schooling - especially traditional public school - already has plenty of support by virtue of having forcibly muscled out most other options through the first three-quarters of the 20th century. It doesn't need anyone else's voice. And, in fact, it's not really a choice due to compulsory school attendance laws (i.e., unless a parent chooses another option, attending state-sponsored school is mandatory, not a choice). So efforts to promote choice should emphasize options that are not taxpayer-supported - or, at the very least, those beyond the conventional public schools - rather than giving equal weight to all.

My second concern rests in the fact that - though the NSCW itself asserts that it is "not associated with any legislative lobbying or advocacy" - discussions of school choice almost always morph into endorsement in one way or another of vouchers - i.e., an initiative promoting the idea that private schools and homeschooling parents should be given taxpayer funds to pay for non-public school options. Of course, government school advocates vehemently oppose vouchers, claiming that voucher programs (even those going to charter or magnet public schools) "steal" money from (traditional) public schools. That argument is nothing but a a red herring; in fact, it's the public school scheme as a whole which does the stealing. But I do know that the aphorism "he who pays gets the say" is true. Thus, if government entities "give" private schools and homeschooling parents "government money" (i.e., money that comes from other taxpayers), the government will have a legitimate right to regulate the use of those funds. In other words, if private educational endeavors accept voucher money, bureaucrats can (and will) begin to pass rules about how the money can be spent - i.e., what can and cannot be taught. Thus, the real problem with voucher money is that it is a governmental Trojan Horse, inevitably leading to a loss of academic freedom - a narrowing of real choice - for homeschoolers and private schools.

That said, I do understand why some who choose private schools and some homeschoolers find the idea of vouchers appealing. These good folks look at all the state and federal aid given to public schools (of all iterations), knowing that they were mandated to contribute (via taxation) to the funding despite their own kids not attending public schools and regardless of the fact that they often have moral objections to the content and/or approaches used in those schools. They pay on top of that to cover private school tuition or homeschooling expenses, so the idea of vouchers - "getting some of my money back" - sounds good. And they try to justify their position by asserting (all evidence about the nature of government to the contrary) that bureaucrats "would never" add regulation in exchange for the money.

The answer to the money problem is not, however, government "giving" money to parents or private schools. Instead, government shouldn't be taking our money to begin with, and it's time that advocates for non-public school options begin lobbying for a new paradigm. Rather than government taking money from us to "support public schools" and then "giving" some of it back (with strings) in the form of vouchers, it would be better if those who do not use public schools (i.e., any schooling option supported by taxpayer dollars) were simply exempted from paying school taxes all together (and this should apply as well to those who have no children). We could then use what would have gone to support government schools to cover our own children's educational expenses - without any regulation since government would never have touched the money.

The only people who should be mandated to pay into the school system are those who use it, with others contributing voluntarily if they so choose. This idea will surely make public school advocates' heads explode. They will scream that public schools will never have enough money if school taxes don't apply to everyone - but they already scream about not having enough now. The fact is that the way the factory school system operates means there will never be enough money in the eyes of its supporters. So we can't worry about that. What we need is justice - i.e., the ability of those who do not use and do not agree with state-sponsored schooling to opt out of paying for it.

My concern about open-ended school choice initiatives is that most people still aren't thinking outside the box like that. The furtherest some will go is talk of vouchers rather than true freedom - and I am too much of a realist about the nature of government to ever support that.

Hence the reasons my feelings about NSCW are complicated. I support parental rights even for those who choose differently for their kids than I ever would...and even though I urge anyone who asks to put private, independent home education at the top of the list. But I don't think public (i.e., compulsory) school really needs a seat at the choice table. I absolutely support the proliferation of options...but I absolutely oppose voucher schemes of all stripes and don't ever want my support of the former seen as endorsement of the latter.

I may at some point decide to host a NSCW event. I was watching a New York-based morning show this week and noticed a very large contingent of kids and adults hugging the outdoor rope line and holding signs promoting "National Catholic Schools Week." Clearly, they were using NSCW to celebrate their particular choice - i.e., for Catholic schools. So if I do hold my own event, it would geared specifically to promote private homeschooling - not all choice in general - in order to encourage those interested in learning more about what that means, and I'd be sure to explain my caveats to the larger initiative.

That said, I do encourage all parents to fully investigate all the options - to not default to traditional public school (or public school in general) just because it's the biggest and loudest kid on the block. Even though compulsory school attendance laws are abominable - that's a topic for another post - it is a parent's responsibility to see that his/her children are educated, not according to current state-school norms but, rather, in keeping with what the parent knows to be best for the children's ultimate good and long-term well-being. Whatever you choose, be absolutely sure - without compromise for convenience - that it comports with your parental convictions and values.

October 9, 2019

A Letter to Teen Girls

One of my daughters, Rachel, loves to write and maintains two separate blogs. My other daughter, Abbie, has a lot to say, but doing so in writing is not her default. She dutifully completes the writing tasks I assign and does a good job with them but isn't generally passionate about written composition. Recently, though, she's had enough interest in a few particular topics to delve more intently into the writing process, and her latest narrative essay is something about which she feels so strongly that she wanted to share it. Thus, it's my privilege and joy to hand over this space to my precious Abbie today.

*****

Dear tween, teen, and young adult girls currently struggling to find who you are and what you stand for:

This is a letter written to you in love from a fellow girl who has had her ups and downs throughout her tween and early teen years. At the time of this writing, I am seventeen and a soon-to-be high school graduate. Hopefully knowing where I am in my own life will put your mind at ease, as I am not far removed from the stress of being a teenager and I can truly empathize and understand your situations. I will be including my testimony also, so you can see my background. But, before I delve into what I really want to say to you, there are a few things I assume are true about you, your current state of mind and your situation; if one or more of these rings true to you, then I urge you to keep reading.

Number one: You are a girl between the ages of thirteen and twenty. Number two: You feel a disconnect with the world around you and don’t know how to reconnect. Number three: You have a generally negative outlook on life and are disinterested in most everything. And number four: There is no one around that you feel would understand your emotions and problems, so you bottle up everything. These are my assumptions because I have gone through these things and I can only speak from my own experience, which I suppose I should include.

I was raised in a Christian home, my parents were and still are happily married, I have one sister who doubles as my best friend, and I have been homeschooled for my entire life. I was a pretty normal kid up to the age of 13, when I “finally” became a teenager, a far off goal that I was all too happy to have finally reached. It was around this time that I started to express myself through my fashion, which at the time consisted of everything bright, glittery, or patterned. Around this time, I also started to get involved with teen drama. Many of the girls I hung out with had a generally snarky attitude towards parents and/or other young girls who, for one reason or another, “weren’t good enough” to be in the popular circle. These were the people who most molded my thoughts at the time and I became annoyed and distant with my own family, believing that everything they said or believed was wrong, simply because they were my family.

This phase lasted until I was about fourteen and then I moved into what my family and I now call the “goth phase.” After having a falling out with a few friends, I remember being very sad and in my own head about it for maybe a month. Then I went shopping for a whole new wardrobe and bought all black, white, and grey clothes. This was a rather drastic change from the bright neon colors from the previous year. I also experimented more with makeup and took to wearing a whole lot of very dark eye makeup, and I dyed my hair such a dark brown that it looked black. This didn’t all happen overnight; it was semi-gradual.

You may be asking now, “Okay, so you tried a look that didn’t work. What’s the harm?” And to that I will tell you this: At least for me, the way I dress reflects my state of mind and which emotions are in control at the moment, and this was especially true for the “goth phase.” I continued to distance myself from my family, especially my mom. I also backed away from spending time with friends. I always felt lonely, but I was disinterested in anything around me so I chose not to go to any event or activity. I became even more withdrawn and my inner monologue consisted of self-righteousness and self-pity for my “terrible life” and “awful, closed minded parents.” I wouldn’t say I “had depression,” but I was quite depressed.

The worst of my angst came, though, when I decided that the answer to fill the void and emptiness in my life was to set up multiple email accounts and join an online dating site. I was fifteen at that point and wanted to see what guys thought of me. I went back and forth in my head about whether I should or shouldn’t do it, but once I signed up for one, I was in. I faked my profile and said I was 18, as that was the youngest these sites allow. Somehow it didn’t occur to me that many of the people on the site could have faked their ages and profiles too, and for all I know I was talking to forty-something predators. I don’t remember how long I was on this site, but it was at least a month, and one day I started to feel very guilty about what I had done. This persisted for a few days and I finally deleted the account, or so I thought. Then about a month after I got off the site, an email from it came into my regular email - not the secret email I had set up, but the normal one. The normal account was linked to my mom’s email so she could actually see it. I am still baffled as to how it came to that address, but I am so glad now that it did. After she found the dating account, which I guess I hadn’t taken down correctly, my mom and I had a very open conversation about the sadness I felt. I remember my mom praying over me multiple times that day. I look back at that conversation as the turning point for me.

In the past fifteen months, God has been changing me. I have gotten a job, grown closer to my family, and made deep friendships with good people. I feel a general sense of peace and and contentment in my soul that I have never felt before. But, of course, getting out of that dark place was gradual. I am still a very private person and have to force myself to express my feelings to others instead of just waiting around for someone to literally guess what’s wrong. I still struggle with being honest and that is probably a tendency I will live with forever. But through the grace of God, I can get better at it. Sometimes I wonder where I would be in my life now if my mom hadn’t gotten that email. I think I would still be in a dark mindset feeling sorry for myself and blaming everyone around me for my own problems. God has blessed my so much by giving me a loving and supportive family to whom I can open up, and I hope that my experience will help me give advice to girls in a similar state of mind.

If you’re going through a rough time, I would greatly encourage you to talk to a parent. If you have a parent who you know will love you and stand by you no matter what you have done, please, please, please talk to him or her. It will be difficult to open up - I know I still struggle with it - but every time you push yourself to tell someone about your problems, it will get easier. Unfortunately, people are not mind readers, and you cannot expect your parent to come to you one day and guess every single thought you have had and every single problem you face. Sometimes you have to be the one to make the first move; you need to be the one to walk up to your parent and say, “Can I talk to you about something going on in my life?” Most parents will be concerned at this phrase, but they will also love you and be so happy that you trust them to help you.

I do understand that not all families are supportive and receptive. If you are going through a hard time and you have tried to speak to your parents but they are unresponsive, then your second option is to go to someone from an older generation who can help guide you through your emotions and help you pick yourself up. A good example of this type of person would be a pastor, aunt, uncle, or teacher. If you can’t find an older person, then the last resort would be to go to a friend. I list friends as a last option because I feel a person at your same maturity level might accidentally justify your feelings and sadness. It is absolutely okay to be sad if you are, but it is not okay to simply stay that way.

My last bit of advice to you girls is this: Open a Bible and read. When you do this, please pray that God will lead you to a passage he wants you to hear. Also, please keep your heart open to what God may be saying to you. You may not think he cares but he does, and when you read his Word with a desire to hear him, it doesn’t matter if you don’t find the passages applicable to your life or not. What matters is that you are in the Word and it is in your head. God loves you, and, if you let him, he will help you. But you must want to be helped, and - from someone who has been there - I know you may not think you need it. Let me tell you now, though, that you and your burden are in my prayers and, although I can give advice, I know you are the deciding factor. Only you can decide that you want to change. But please know that you are loved.

Love,
Abbie



*****
Photo Credit: Art Ranked

April 23, 2019

Happy Birthday, Mr. Shakespeare

When I was in high school, I managed to avoiding reading anything by William Shakespeare. For some reason, the oft-obligatory reading of Romeo and Juliet didn't happen in my freshman English class, and sophomore English was a combination of "communications" and composition, devoid of any literature study. Then, as an upperclassman, I filled my schedule with advanced science classes appropriate for a wannabe veterinarian, and met my English requirements with more composition classes and a couple semesters of "theater arts."

And that was fine with me. You see, I'd naively latched onto the idea that Shakespeare was "really hard," and, as an insecure perfectionist, I didn't want to risk my GPA on the supposedly incomprehensible work of a dead British playwright. Give me, instead, the comparative safety of shark dissections, chemical equations, and essay writing!

In college, I rather quickly realized that life as a vet wouldn't be for me (thank you, Calculus 101, for so unapologetically pointing that out!) and then spent several semesters trying out a variety of academic majors. Ironically, I eventually landed in the humanities and found myself considering an English major. But Mr. Shakespeare's potential to tank my GPA still terrified me, so I avoided him by choosing a general "Humanistic Studies" degree instead of the more specific English major just so I could skip his eponymous class.

A few years after receiving my generic bachelor's, I returned to school to obtain a certification to teach English as a Second Language. I slugged my way through some hard-core linguistics classes, still believing Shakespeare would be harder, and eventually got a job teaching at a public/government middle school. A few years later, I transferred to the high school level, delighted to be assigned the upper-level ESL kids (i.e., those almost ready to "graduate" from the program into mainstream classes). But there was a catch: In order for the students to receive English, not merely elective, credit for the classes, the teacher had to be certified in Grades 6-12 English Language Arts in addition to ESL.

Given the option of taking additional coursework or being assigned to other classes, I headed back to the university. To obtain the certification I sought, I had to earn an English minor, which required - unsurprisingly - that terrifying Shakespeare course.

My perfectionism had abated a bit, but I still wanted to get "good grades" so I was nervous. However, my self-confidence had increased enough that I felt I could manage to earn the A I wanted if I just worked hard enough. Thus, I actually went into the class with curious anticipation.

And it didn't take me long to realize that, while reading Shakespeare certainly does require focus (and, in many instances, a good side-by-side modern "translation" to confirm the meaning of obscure phrases), it is well worth the effort and not nearly as difficult as I'd imagined. His use of metaphor! His understanding of human nature! His turn of a phrase...over and over again! In fact, I deem that Shakespeare class to be one of the best courses I've ever taken, simply because it afforded me the opportunity to "bathe" in the work of a master writer for 15 weeks.

Besides enthusiastically teaching both Romeo and Juliet and Julius Caesar to my students during my classroom tenure, I went on to jump at the chance to teach King Lear to middle school-aged students at a homeschool co-op. And when they were only nine and 10, I introduced my daughters to The Bard, starting with Bard of Avon by Diane Stanley and Peter Vennema, an excellent picture book biography, and then introducing them to Tales from Shakespeare by Marcia Williams and a picture book adaptation of Romeo and Juliet by Andrea Hopkins. And later - as we marked the 448th anniversary of Shakespeare's birth in 2012 - I read a prose narrative of Macbeth from Charles and Mary Lamb's Tales from Shakespeare, delighting as both girls hung on every word and immediately asked for another story from the book. I happily obliged, and urged them to read as many of Shakepeare's original texts as possible over the next few years (and to re-read them as adults).

My only regret about my "love affair" with Shakespeare is that it didn't begin sooner. But I've got plenty of time to make up for lost time. And, of course, I saved my copy of The Complete Works of William Shakespeare, so I've got everything he wrote right at my fingertips.

*****
Photo Credit: Glyn1

December 11, 2018

How the Common Core Turned Me into a Pack Rat

Anyone who knows me understands that I am not a pack rat by nature. Oh, I have plenty of "stuff," and I do keep some things for sentimental reasons. But I don't like clutter.

In fact, I enjoy being able to de-junk and keep things looking organized. And my penchant for doing so extended for a long time to homeschool curriculum, motivating me to quickly sell anything with which we'd finished rather than allow it to take up room on our bookshelves. As an added bonus, the money I earned through selling our used curriculum helped to fund my purchases of new material.

But all that changed in 2013.

That summer, in the midst of an on-going research project and in light of several disturbing political developments, I became deeply convicted that I was no longer to sell anything of value in terms of children's education - not curriculum, not other educational resources, and not even children's literature. Instead, I decided to save and store everything I had worth keeping. And I determined to trust the Lord to provide for us financially for the purchase of new material in lieu of extra funds from the sale of old things. Beyond that, I also worked to find room in our budget to re-purchase copies of good material I'd sold in the past, all of which I'd pack up into totes as it arrived. I knew I might end up with rows of totes stacked floor-to-ceiling, but I didn't care.

And I have the common core standards initiative to "thank" for my about-face.

In my research, I learned that the publishers of about 50% of homeschool-related materials have chosen to remain independent of the common core, deciding not to change their resources for the sake of that misguided governmental overreach. Additionally, about 15% have not altered their content even though they have chosen to show "correlations" to the common core, and another 10% have "ancillary connections" via some outside vendors they use in their packaged curriculum programs. But that latter 25% has, in fact, acquiesced to the common core on some level. And another 25% of publishers homeschoolers might use has drunk the common core Kool-Aid, changing their materials - in whole or in part - for the express purpose of aligning with the initiative.

That looks positive, overall, for those of us wanting independence from the common core; we still appear to have plenty of unaligned or marginally connected options. However, a few companies that initially pledged their commitment to independence later chose to correlate. And I knew from my research that a couple of well-known, popular curriculum providers that are currently correlated are very likely destined to become aligned - changing content for the common core - as they make revisions to their materials for new editions. On the other hand, I have been assured by a number of publishers that they will simply close rather than compromise their principles for the common core, and I support and commend that stand. But, of course, if they do cease to exist, we homeschoolers will lose our access to their wonderful products, the same as if they'd changed to align.

I've spoken to some folks who believe that deep concern about the common core is unnecessary and even alarmist. They feel this is but the latest passing fad in "educational reform" that will probably fall to the wayside in due time, leaving intact plenty of educationally sound homeschool resources free of government interference. And I hope with all my heart they'll be proven right. But I've learned too much since 2013 about the history of "educational reform" - and pay way too much attention to current events - to embrace their cockeyed optimism. The Lord convicted me to do something and so do something I did.

Some have said, "Well, what if your girls don't homeschool?" And, of course, one or both may decide against homeschooling, a decision I will work very hard as a grandmother to respect even though I would be grieved for my grandchildren. However, the girls are currently extremely committed to home education - they see its benefits and understand God's call on parents to train up and raise their own children for Him - and we are already praying that their husbands - whoever God has in mind for each - will have the same convictions. In fact, each of my girls has indicated at this point that she will not consider marriage to a man who will not allow her to homeschool. And so I feel compelled to help them provide for that as I'm able.

Of course, it's possible they won't want to use what I'm saving - and, by God's grace, they will still have at least a few decent options beyond what I'll have collected. I'm perfectly fine with that. I just want to make sure they have something useful in a worst-case scenario. And even if other good resources are still available down the road, perhaps they will decide to go with what I've saved in order to be good stewards of their families' finances. Then my saved items will have served as a sort of homeschooling trousseau, and that will bless my heart.

Thus, I launched out on my mission. I made a list of good (still unaligned) materials I'd used in the past and then sold. I began to purchase replacement copies, and continued to do so until I'd "re-stocked" everything I wanted to have. And since Fall 2013, I stopped selling books after we finished them; instead, I made room in storage totes, selling only a few items that likely won't be useful in the future.

I also bought an extra copy of each consumable book in order to keep a "clean copy" available for future use - because, though I am committed to complying with copyright law, if the materials are not available years from now, making copies won't violate the law at that point. And I've saved all the children's literature we've had in the house - after parsing through it to eliminate twaddle - because, tragically, part of the common core agenda even involves making politically correct revisions to literature. Thus, the girls won't be able to count on original versions being available down the road.

I know all of this sounds to some as if I must be wearing a tinfoil hat while I write. Think what you will, but I can assure you I'm not paranoid. I am simply a realist. I certainly don't take becoming an educational resources pack rat lightly; it does go against my tendency to be minimalist and efficient and it looks "extreme" to those who don't take the time to understand the situation. But, frankly, I don't care. As I mentioned, my observations of the world around me have led me to conclude that I must err on the side of caution. Thus, I will risk one day being considered a silly curriculum hoarder over failing to provide quality, non-revisionist educational resources for my children to use with their children.

Gladly and unapologetically.

*****
Photo Credit: Jimmie

December 6, 2018

On Media Choices: Different Is Not Deprived


Every once in a while I have an interesting conversation with someone about media choices - specifically, what I choose to read or watch and what I choose for my kids. Of course, a lot of my friends and I have similar views so we affirm each other's choices. And sometimes the other person thinks I'm too liberal - for example, an acquaintance once questioned the decision my husband and I made to take our daughters to see Brave due to moments of admittedly less-than-wholesome content peppering the film. But, more often than not, a person who questions my decisions about media believes I'm "too conservative."

I certainly won't dispute the fact that I'm discriminating. For example, I don't read the "latest craze" in books, tune into a popular TV show, or go out to watch the most recent chick flick just because "everyone else" does. I also have no interest in what now passes for popular music, preferring instead to listen to talk radio, classical music, or Christian stations. Similarly, we're careful about the movies we attend as a family - and those we buy for our home collection. I also monitor the types of books my daughters choose - guarding against both inappropriate content and "twaddle" - and have happily encouraged their disinterest in many things related to the "pop culture" that ensnares many of their same-age peers.

Am I depriving myself or my kids? Hardly. Lest you doubt, come on over and take a look at the girls' movie collection, which includes well over 100 titles representing everything from Pixar to Broadway musicals to current action/adventure and intense drama - any of which they're free to choose for a movie time - or tune in with us when we enjoy Mythbusters or Dirty Jobs together on TV. Likewise, take a look at their home library, overflowing with great books from a wide variety of genres, and tag along on weekly visits to the library and to any of the handful of movies we see in the theater each year. As for me, I probably watch too much TV and have more books on my personal "must-read" list than I'll have time for in the next 10 years.

Yes, we eschew a lot that interests some of our friends and neighbors - for example, of the more than 800 stations available to us on cable TV, we gravitate toward less than half a dozen, ruling out many based on our estimation that they're inappropriate for us. But choosing a different path than the one chosen by the majority is not the same thing as being deprived. In fact, our "different" media choices aren't a burden at all because they simply flow out of our choice to see all of life differently. Specifically, we've embraced the truth of what the Bible says about our real citizenship as believers in Christ: we are merely aliens here on this Earth (1 Peter 2.10-12). In other words, contemporary American culture is not our real, ultimate culture, and so we needn't (and in many cases shouldn't) have an affinity for it.

In that regard, the final arbiter of what I choose to read or watch - or what I choose for my kids - is not what might seem "fun" or what others we know are doing. Instead, it's God's Word, which, as former blogger Shannon McKee points out, "...is unlike any other book and is the standard by which I judge all other [media] - fiction or non-fiction, Christian or non-Christian. It is the source of Truth and God's own letter directly to the human race." Thus, I rely on verses like Philippians 4.8 for guidance, which makes it clear that, in all things, we need to seek "...whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable ... anything [that] is excellent or praiseworthy." Or we can think about it a different way, asking ourselves, "What would I feel comfortable reading if Jesus were looking over my shoulder or watching if he were sitting next to me?"

Some might argue that, while I have the choice to make such decisions for myself, I really ought not  "limit" my children in the same way. But the truth is that all parents have the right and responsibility to raise their own children as they see fit, whether that's according to a biblical worldview or something else. Besides that, in our case, each of our daughters has already made a personal commitment to put Jesus at the hub of her life, and so living according to a biblical standard is no more a burden for them than it is for my husband or me. They see and think about and value things differently than many of their peers, but they know it and it doesn't bother them. And we don't prevent them from knowing about books, shows, or movies we choose to avoid; instead, we talk about media choices all the time, discussing our reasons for partaking or not. In our family, our media choices are simply about practicing Christ-following discipleship together.

Of course, one thing we greatly appreciate about having been placed by the Lord in this country is the freedom we have to live out our faith convictions about media (and anything else) without government interference or any serious persecution. And I likewise respect others' right to make media choices for themselves and their children according to their beliefs and values. I'm not afraid to express my opinions about certain books, shows, movies, and music, and sometimes choose to engage in what might become spirited discussion about them. But, ultimately, I understand that each person gets to make his own choices and is free choose for his children. I might not agree, but I won't try to push someone out of her comfort zone in order to comply with my values. And I can only hope for the same level of respect toward my choices, no matter how "different" they might seem.


December 3, 2018

It’s Time for a Cease-Fire


I wrote the following piece for an issue of the Celebrate Kids' email newsletter a few years ago...and I mean every word. 
Education is a hot-button issue.
In fact, it’s exceedingly rare to find a person who doesn’t have an opinion about what’s “best” in terms of kids’ learning. Some insist that public school offers the best opportunities and should be mandatory for all, and others maintain that homeschooling is the only way to go. Still others assert that private school provides the best of both worlds. And when we add the voices supporting each of the vast, almost infinite, variety of options within “the big three” – charter, virtual, voucher, Charlotte Mason, unit studies, classical, unschooling, Christian, Montessori, alternative…just to name a few – we find ourselves surrounded by an ear-splitting cacophony of aggressive activism.
That said, opinions in and of themselves are not bad. And children’s education is so important that the existence of strong opinions is understandable. In fact, anyone who knows me personally is familiar with my background as a classroom teacher in “at-risk” schools, the pride I now take in being a homeschool mom, and my particular, deeply held convictions about educational theory and practice. 
 But it’s time to poke our heads up out of the trenches and get some perspective.  
First, we must each realize that we don't have a right to an opinion about what's best for anyone else's child. My husband and I fully considered every educational option, have taken into account the ramifications of each, and have come to a conclusion about what's best for our children. We cannot be swayed...and we shouldn't have to endure unsolicited lectures - or "helpful suggestions" - from proponents of other options. But neither do we have a right to push our views onto parents who have chosen differently. In fact, unless we’re asked, we have no standing from which to state an opinion. Out of respect for parental authority, we must assume that all parents have fully researched the matter for their own children and have come to their conclusions in good faith. We might not agree, but it's simply not our place to butt in.
Conversely, we must also decide to stop being offended by others’ choices. My friend’s decision to enroll her children in the local private school is not an indictment of my homeschooling. My meme celebrating homeschooling is not an attack on a fellow church member’s decision to send her children to the public school down the street. And my relative’s announcement that his daughter made all-state for the public school’s volleyball team is not a jab at schooling options that offer different benefits. It’s possible that a rude, immature person might actually intend to offend in such a way, but why do we let ourselves assume the worst? 
The “school wars” have grown tiresome. And no one will ever win if we insist on continuing to usurp others’ parental authority over their own children. But if we can choose to agree that the widest possible variety of options should always be available and that each child’s parents have the right to decide for their own kids, we can reach détente. It's time for a cease-fire.
Some people will have a hard time believing I mean these words because I am such an unflinching apologist for home education. In fact, I am fully convinced that any diligent parent - regardless of educational background or current circumstances - really can successfully homeschool, and I am profoundly and deeply troubled by much of what occurs within institutional schools of any stripe. And if I'm being completely transparent, I'll admit that I wish every school - public or private - would close tomorrow because every parent had withdrawn every child in favor of parent-led, home-based education. Of course, I don't go around saying that (despite admitting it here in this post!), but my strong advocacy in favor of home education is certainly not a secret. So I can understand why some would assume I don't really believe in parental choice.

And, though I cannot now recall specific circumstances, I'm quite sure I've crossed the line and "pushed" in regards to homeschooling. I'll probably do it again at some point...because I'm human. I'm not making excuses - when I've disrespected a parent's authority over her own children in the past and if I do it again - I have been - and will be - wrong. Without question. I should endeavor to prevent it from happening again...because I'm serious about what I say in the article about parental authority.

That doesn't mean I'll stop celebrating the joys of homeschooling. It's a wonderful endeavor - even in its unavoidable travails and struggles - and I feel the need to defend it because it is too often vilified by ill-informed blowhards who jump to conclusions and make ridiculous over-generalizations. Because it's not at all mainstream - despite its long, successful history in the U.S. and around the world - it needs vocal support, and I'm happy to speak up for it. But, as I suggest in the article, my advocacy for home education should be seen as just that - support in favor of one particular thing in which I believe. And even when I write or talk about concerns with the system of institutional schooling - which I do on a limited basis and only with a matter of especially grave concern - I absolutely do not do so with a hidden agenda of seeking to shame parents who've chosen to use such schools. I cannot speak for anyone else who promotes homeschooling, and you'll have to choose to take me at my word, but that is the God's honest truth. 

At root, I stand deeply and profoundly in favor of home education and just as deeply and profoundly for parental authority. One does not trump the other...which means - from the bottom of my heart - that as much as I beg you to honor the decision of parents who home-educate - please stop trying to convince us that we're wrong! - I do fully and completely respect your choice to choose another option. I would not choose it, but your kids are not my kids and I know my place.

Bottom line: I desperately wish we could all agree on that cease-fire, and I hope I live to see it.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...