Showing posts with label Home Education: Reading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Home Education: Reading. Show all posts

August 27, 2020

The Art of Buddy-Reading

When my girls were first learning to read, I stumbled (by accident as I tried various activities with them) upon a process I came to call buddy-reading. It worked really well for us, and I've recommended it regularly to many others since. But almost every time I suggest it, the person with whom I'm talking asks, "Buddy-reading? What's that?"

In a nutshell, buddy-reading is a way to help new or struggling readers practice the skills associated with reading - decoding, comprehension, etc. - in a positive, low-key manner. Buddy-reading also helps a parent understand a child's reading strengths and weaknesses in the context of relationship.

That last point - in the context of relationship - is key. In fact, it's the key to the entire process of homeschooling, as it is a loving parent-child relationship - not turning our homes into mini-schools - that fuels effective home education. That's why - with helping a child learn to read and everything else - I advocate ignoring the regimented, standardized approach the schools take in favor of seeing home education as a simple extension of parenting.

In terms of buddy-reading, this translates into employing the approach most of us associate with reading aloud to our babies and preschoolers with our older, learning-to-read kids as well, and keeping things easy-going, warm, and relational - starting only when each child has actually demonstrated readiness to learn to read - instead of making it a formal, mechanistic process.

With that in mind, this is what I did with my children as each was learning to read and then growing in fluency - roughly from age five to about nine or 10 in our case. I started out using just the Amish Pathway Reading series - only the primers, not the workbooks - which I highly recommend, until the girls were about eight and nine, and then eventually added in my Readers' Workshop tool as well.
  1. Find a comfortable, cozy spot - such as your living room couch or propped up with pillows in your bed - and cuddle up with your child, book in hand. The idea is to associate reading with warmth and positive feelings;
  2. Read the title of the book or story aloud and then take a few minutes to turn the pages and talk - conversationally, not in quiz-mode - about the illustrations. Gently encourage the child's use of descriptive, expressive language and see if he can make predictions about the storyline based on the pictures;
  3. Ask the child if he would like to read the first page - or if he would prefer for you to. Honor his decision and start accordingly. Then alternate every other page (i.e., if you read the first page, the child reads the second, etc.);
  4. When you read, be sure the child can see the text and encourage him to pay attention, but don't run your finger under the words. Aim for the process to be as natural as possible - as when you read aloud at story time - and rely on the appropriateness and topic of the text to draw him in;
  5. When your child reads, let him run his own finger under the words if it helps him; if it doesn't, don't require it. When he gets to a word he cannot decode, just supply him for it (without making him labor over it or "sound it out") and keep going. Provide appropriate praise as he proceeds;
  6. Read all the way through the story, alternating pages. As you read and/or at the end, take time to discuss - again, in conversation, not quiz-style. Think about how you'd talk about a favorite book with an adult friend and use that as your model as you talk about the story with your child. When the discussion seems to be over, tell your child what a good job he did, give him a hug, and send him on his way;
  7. The next day, get situated in a similarly comfortable manner and pull out the same book/story. Talk about the story for a few minutes if the child wants to - i.e., if he says he thought about some new things related to the story since the previous day - and then ask him to begin reading it aloud to you;
  8. For this second reading, the goal is for the child to read the entire story to you. But allow him to ask for help when he gets stuck on a word, and oblige if he asks you to read a page now and then after he's read several. If there's a word that you know - from past experience - he can sound out rather quickly, encourage him to do so. But if it's a sight word or a newer decodable word, just supply it to him so the flow of the reading continues and the experience stays positive;
  9. At the end of the story, praise him appropriately for reading the entire story to you. Then ask him to tell you the story in his own words. This is a comprehension check - no need for quizzes or tests when you've got a relationship with your child! - and you'll quickly know if he grasped the gist of the story. Then give him a hug and move on with your day;
  10. In the evening on the second day, arrange for the child to read the same story aloud to your spouse - so, yes, the child gets three readings of each story, which builds confidence and "muscle memory." Tell your spouse ahead of time to listen actively as the child reads and to simply supply any words on which the child stumbles or asks for help, without pressure. And encourage your spouse to talk about the story with the child afterward - again, in conversation mode, not quiz/school-style - and praise him for the effort.
  11. Move on to a new story the next day. Rinse, wash, repeat.
I know this seems almost too easy - and probably leads you to wonder, "What about phonics instruction?" I'm definitely a phonics fan - and I worked on letter identification, matching sounds to letters, and sounding-out and blending, etc.,  with my kids before we ever began the buddy-reading process. In fact, I spent a pretty penny (far too much!) on a bells-and-whistles phonics program I thought was the Holy Grail of reading instruction. But God blessed me with a right-brained learner in one of my kids - meaning that she learns whole-to-part, not part-to-whole. As such, she had a hard time with isolated phonics lessons but began to thrive as we read - buddy-read - the Amish Pathway series, because the real stories provided her with context that enabled her to decode unfamiliar words. In fact, even her left-brained sister did better with her reading within the context of real stories. And one strength of the Amish series over randomly picked "easy-reader" or favorite picture books from our shelves was the leveled, incremental method built into it - so, even though we were reading real stories, they were also instructional and phonics-based by design.

As we dug into the series - and grew in relationship - via our daily buddy-reading, I was able to challenge the girls to pause now and then and really "sound out" a new word instead of just saying it for them - so I still employed phonics in that way as well. But I found that the girls rather naturally took that on for themselves more often than not as their confidence increased and their enjoyment of buddy-reading grew. Once we started buddy-reading - leaving the kitchen table and the worksheets and drill-and-kill lessons in favor of this more holistic approach - all the pieces fell into place rather quickly and learning to read became a joy, not a burden.

December 17, 2018

Tina's Top 100 (Or So) Children's Titles

A few days ago, I wrote about the BBC Book List, a catalog of 100 books for teens and/or adults that someone at the BBC deems "important." Though the criteria by which they were chosen remain a mystery, as do the BBC's reasons for believing it "knows best" in terms of good literature, the compilation was nonetheless thought-provoking. And writing about which BBC books I've read got me thinking about something else: What would be on my list - particularly for younger kids - were I to come up with one?

As I've mentioned before, I believe in giving kids choice, so I have never mandated that my children read particular titles. But I have spent an entire generation's worth of time with children and young people - teaching in government schools for nine years and now, for the past 18, raising and home-educating my daughters and also caring during a large chunk of that time for others' young children in my home to supplement our income. Thus, while I don't consider myself a "literature expert" - and I know there's a lot of wonderful children's literature of which I'm not aware - it's fair to say that I have at least been steeped in children's books for a good portion of my life. So I have seen a lot, and I developed strong convictions about what I considered appropriate for my children and the others in my care.

I frequented our public library for years, filling our "book basket" each month with wonderful titles recommended in the parent manuals of the homeschool curricula I used at the time. But I'm also a children's book "junkie," devoting whole walls throughout our home to shelves for literature we own. To this day, I'm always on the lookout for more - and I'm saving all of these titles and many, many more for my girls to use with their children one day.

Even so, I am picky. I love quality picture books - those with both beautiful illustrations and good writing. But, with both picture and chapter books, I gravitated toward "substance" and classics...and newer books I felt might be modern classics. Plus, I made sure that what we had available generally supported - or at least did not blatantly contradict - our family's faith and worldview perspective. So you wouldn't find a lot of what I consider to be the children's lit version of "pulp fiction" because, simply put and - and to quote the 19th century educator Charlotte Mason - I didn't (and still don't) want my children spending their time on twaddle.

Thus, everything that made its way onto our shelves is decent material. The titles I suggest were the ones to which my kids gravitated for both read-alouds and independent reading - a mix of picture and chapter books, a variety of genres and subject matter, in a range roughly appropriate for ages three through about 10 or 11.

And it's actually quite a bit more than 100. That's because a few authors are so prolific and wonderful that we own a bunch of their works, but I couldn't see listing just one each among so many great titles - or eliminating some great books in order to list my seven Cynthia Rylant selections separately, for example. But it's my list so I can do that.

Of course, you may or may not agree with my choices - and, again, I claim no special status as a "guru" of children's literature so you're perfectly welcome to your opinions. But if you don't like mine, you'll have to make your own list because this one stands as-is...for now. :^)

******

GENERAL / CONTEMPORARY FICTION

1. Abuela - Arthur Dorros (Picture Book - P)
A sweet tale - complete with Spanish language vocabulary - about an adventure undertaken by a girl and her grandma

2. Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day - Judith Viorst (P)
Poor Alexander is beleaguered with the "traumas" of childhood in this book - and the couple of sequels in which he is also the protagonist. It really helped my kids see the lighter side of their own bad days.

3. Because of Winn-Dixie - Kate DiCamillo (Chapter Book - C)
This is a gem in terms of contemporary fiction! The protagonist is simply a normal girl, nothing near the snotty, worldly kids found in so much of current children's literature. She has very real problems, but very real support as well. And - added bonus - the movie adaptation is nearly as good as the book.

4. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever - Barbara Robinson (C)
A story of redemption that will make you cry

5. Billy and Blaze books - C.W. Anderson (P)
I remember reading some of these as a kid, and they're still around - nice adventure stories.

6. Blueberries for Sal - Robert McCloskey (P)
A classic, as are other McCloskey titles (Make Way for Ducklings comes to mind)

7. The Boxcar Children series - Gertrude C. Warner (C)
The protagonists of this wholesome mystery-adventure series are four orphaned children. If your child likes the first, you can easily find more in the set.

8. The Button Box - Margarette S. Reid (P)
A boy explores his grandma's button box. This book encouraged us to create our own button box, which was fun and educational (for sorting activities, for example).

9. Cam Jansen books - David Adler (C)
My older daughter loved these simple mystery books. And the more I read of children's literature, the more I discovered you probably can't go wrong with any David Adler books.

10. Capyboppy - Bill Peet (C)
Did you ever buy a new car and suddenly see models just like it everywhere you looked? That happened to us after my younger daughter read this book - about a rainforest animal called a capybara. None of us had ever heard of it before but, suddenly, before we knew it, we were seeing and hearing about capybaras at every turn! It's a delightful story...even if you never hear about capys again.

11. Eric Carle books (P)
  • Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?
  • From Head to Toe
  • A House for a Hermit Crab
  • Panda Bear, Panda Bear, What Do You See?
  • Polar Bear, Polar Bear, What Do You Hear?
  • Rooster's Off to See the World
  • The Tiny Seed
  • The Very Busy Spider
  • The Very Hungry Caterpillar
  • The Very Lonely Firefly
  • The Very Quiet Cricket
What can I say other than Eric Carle is Eric Carle? His stuff is simply wonderful! We especially liked his "very -- insect" series here. Later my daughters loved to read these to the girls for whom I babysat.

12. Chicka Chicka Boom Boom - Bill Martin Jr. (P)
An ABC pattern book with a great rhythm

13. Charlotte's Web - E.B. White (C)
An all-time children's classic, pure and simple

14. Christina Katerina and the Box - Patricia Lee Gauch (P)
This is another title I read as a child. As an adult, I was clearly the mom in the story, and my girls were Christina Katerina! If you have a creative child who makes the most of the boxes in which his or her toys come, you'll love this.

15. Clementine - Sara Pennypacker (C)
I like that Clementine is a high-energy girl who sometimes gets into trouble - that's reality - without being sassy on purpose. There are sequels to this original, though we didn't read them.

16. Corduroy books - Don Freeman (P)
I don't like everything Freeman writes, but this series about a young girl's favorite stuffed animal is sweet.

17. Dr. Seuss books (P)
  • And to Think that I Saw It on Mulberry Street
  • Dr. Seuss' ABCs
  • Green Eggs and Ham
  • Oh, the Thinks You Can Think
  • One Fish, Two Fish, Red Fish, Blue Fish
Of course, I had to include Ted Geisel - and we actually have at least 20 of his books. As a representative sample, these are the ones we read and enjoyed the most.

18. Encore for Eleanor - Bill Peet (P)
This is a tale about an elephant who must make a transition - and how she discovers a talent she never knew she had.

19. Everybody Bakes Bread / Everybody Cooks Rice - Norah Dooley (P)
These two books are among those I consider quality learning books hidden within fiction. In each one, the protagonist visits her neighbors and learns about different cultures' versions of bread or rice in the process. And recipes are included at the end of each story!

20. Frances books - Russell Hoban (P)
There are several titles in the Frances series - all very cute tales that teach gentle lessons about life.

21. The Giving Tree - Shel Silverstein (P)
Another one whose message may make you cry

22. Harriet, You'll Drive Me Wild! - Mem Fox (P)
Do you try very hard to avoid yelling at your child...but sometimes do anyway? If so, you'll love this book. It is just reality and will make both your child and you smile.

23. A House is a House for Me - Mary Ann Hoberman (P)
I read this book just for fun...and also as an introduction to the concept of habitats.

24. Kevin Henkes books (P)
  • Chyrsanthemum
  • Jessica
  • Lilly's Purple Plastic Purse
  • Sheila Rae the Brave
  • A Weekend with Wendell
We loved Kevin Henkes books! They're delightful and hilarious and instructive all at the same time.

25. I Love My Daddy / I Love My Mommy - Scharlotte Rich (C)
Each book has four simple stories demonstrating love between a child and mother or father - great bedtime stories.

26. Ladybug Girl / Ladybug Girl and Bumblebee Boy - David Soman (P)
These are perfect books for encouraging children's imaginations - cute stories that communicate the beauty of pretending.

27. The Littles - John Peterson (C)
There are several in this series as well. They are about the adventures of a family of little people who live in the walls of a house owned by the Bigs.

28. Miss Suzy - Miriam Young (P)
This was actually my husband's favorite book as a child, and I was able several years ago to get him a new copy as a gift. He immediately introduced it - the story of the travails of a little gray squirrel - to our daughters, and they loved it, too.

29. Mrs. McTats and Her Houseful of Cats - Alyssa S. Capucilli (P)
A great rhyming alphabet book

30. Owl Babies - Martin Waddell (P)
This book - the story of three young owls waiting for their mother to return from an evening hunt - was one of the sweetest we ever read!

31. Petunia - Roger Duvoisin (P)
This one has a couple of very important lessons - the value of literacy, the dangers of pride, and the folly of listening to fools - wrapped up in an engaging story about a silly goose.

32. Put Me in the Zoo - Robert Lopshire (P)
Written in the tradition of Dr. Seuss, this is about a leopard who can do amazing things with his spots - another I remember from my childhood.

33. The Rainbow Fish - Marcus Pfister (P)
I really like the lessons of friendship and sharing in this one.

34. Ramona books - Beverly Cleary (C)
There are at least eight titles in the Beezus and Ramona series. As with Clementine and Because of Winn-Dixie, I appreciate that, though Ramona is a normal little girl, she is not sassy or disrespectful. 

35. Sadie and the Snowman - Allen Morgan (P)
The story of how a little girl keeps her snowman "alive" all winter...and beyond

36. Say Hola to Spanish - Susan M. Elya (P)
This is a really fun book that introduces a lot of simple Spanish vocabulary under the guise of rhymes. My daughters remember the words because of the rhyme.

37. The Seven Silly Eaters - Mary Ann Hoberman (P)
If you have a picky eater, you'll want to read this one - so you can see that your situation really isn't all that bad!

38. William Steig books (P)
  • Brave Irene
  • Doctor DeSoto
  • Yellow & Pink
We like his style in all three that we've read, but Yellow & Pink, in particular, is simply an amazing book - a primer for even young children about the debate between creation science and evolution.

39. Tacky books - Helen Lester (P)
At first, I wasn't sure I'd like these books about a rather raucous penguin, even though they came highly recommended. But they've grown on me as I've realized that the lesson they teach is that it's okay - and even good - to be unique.

40. Too Many Tamales - Gary Soto (P)
I read lots of chapter books by Soto with the students I taught during my years as a government school teacher, many of whom could especially relate to his Hispanic protagonists. My girls and I like this picture book because it shows - in a humorous way - the natural consequences when one chooses to break the rules.

41. The Treasure of Pelican Cove - Milly Howard (C)
My older daughter read this book, and there are other titles in the series. It's a mystery-adventure that really held her interest.

42. What! Cried Granny: An Almost Bedtime Story - Kate Lum (P)
This is a hilarious book, pure and simple! I don't want to give it away; you just have to get it.

43. Wild About Books - Judy Sierra (P)
A contemporary book in the Dr. Seuss tradition, it encourages a love of reading in a very fun way.


HISTORICAL FICTION

44. Araminta's Paint Box - Karen Ackerman (P)
I love stories that teach history through the vehicle of an engaging storyline. We first read this one when we learned about the Oregon Trail, and it's helped my girls remember the history.

45. Jan Brett books (P)
  • Annie and the Wild Animals
  • Fritz and the Beautiful Horses
  • The Hat
  • The Mitten
Of these four titles and among the other Brett books we own and have borrowed from the library, Fritz and the Beautiful Horses is our favorite in terms of storyline and message. However, one of the most amazing things about most of Brett's books is her artwork. It's gorgeous, but, beyond that, it's instructive as well...particularly in the realm of teaching children to make predictions as they read. If you don't know what I mean, pick up one of her titles and take a look.

46. Cowgirl Kate books - Erica Silverman (C)
The humor in these books is great. We really did laugh out loud when we read them.

47. Tomie de Paola books (P)
  • Clown of God
  • An Early American Christmas
  • Strega Nona books
Tomie de Paola is another who is so prolific that you could, perhaps, devote a whole shelf to his books alone. We've enjoyed many by him and own these three.

48. The Feather-Bed Journey - Paula K. Feder (P)
If you ever want to teach your pre-teen children anything about The Holocaust, start with this book! It will provide the framework for opening up a discussion about those atrocities - but keep a box of tissues on hand for yourself.

49. The Golly Sisters books - Betsy Byars (C)
These are similar to Cowgirl Kate, in that they're very funny while also providing a conceptual framework for an era of U.S. history - life on the wagon trains in this case.

50. The Josefina Story Quilt - Eleanor Coerr (C)
This is another wagon train story, but is more than that, as you can use also it to gently introduce the concept of death to a young child.

51. Leah's Pony - Elizabeth Friedrich (P)
A great introduction the The Depression era of American history - another tear-jerker

52. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe and others in the Narnia series - C.S. Lewis (C)
No children's book list would be complete without the Chronicles of Narnia series! They are amazing adventure stories but also deep Christian allegories, enjoyable on multiple levels. And the recent movie adaptations - while not entirely true to the books - are well worth viewing.

53. The Little Princess - Frances H. Burnett (C)
Along with Louisa May Alcott's Little Women, this was one of my favorites in my later elementary years, and I read it multiple times. It's a beautiful, moving story, pure and simple.

54. Mandie books - Lois G. Leppard (C)
The many books in this series are about a young girl in Appalachia and various adventures on which she and her friends find themselves. It was my younger daughter's favorite series for  a long time.

55. Miss Rumphius - Barbara Cooney (P)
One of many beautifully-illustrated, simple stories we enjoy, this one is about the world-wide adventures of an intelligent woman whose heart nevertheless remains at home, in her native Maine.

56. My Great-Aunt Arizona - Gloria Houston (P)
Similar to Miss Rumphius, this tells the true story of the author's grandmother growing up in a very rural community at the turn of the last century.

57. Obadiah books - Brinton Turkle (P)
There are several in the series, all describing the adventures of a mischievous Quaker boy and his siblings.

58. Pioneer Cat - William H. Hooks (C)
A sweet chapter book story of a family's journey west on a wagon train

59. Roxaboxen - Alice McLerran (P)
Another celebration of children's imaginations, this one set in the Arizona desert

60. Cynthia Rylant books (P)
  • Christmas in the Country
  • Henry and Mudge books
  • The Old Woman Who Named Things
  • Mr. Putter and Tabby books
  • The Relatives Came
  • Thimbleberry Stories
  • When I Was Young in the Mountains
I love Rylant's books, many of which are based on her own childhood. She is another author whose books I buy without question because I know each one will be good.

61. The Secret Garden - Frances H. Burnett (C)
From the author of The Little Princess, this is another gem.

62. The Secret School - Avi (C)
Set at the turn of the last century in rural Colorado, my older daughter read this, and really enjoyed it. Avi is another trustworthy author.

63. Snow Treasure - Marie McSwigan (C)
I first read this years ago, at the government school middle school where I taught for five years. It's an adventure story, based on real events, of how a Norwegian community keeps its gold from Nazi invaders. 

64. The Tale of Despereaux - Kate DiCamillo (C)
This is a book that made us say, "Wow," when we'd finished. However, I do not recommend the movie adaptation, which barely follows the book's wonderful storyline.

65. When Agnes Caws - Candace Fleming (P)
This is a fun story about a young girl who can imitate any bird call.


NON-FICTION INFORMATION AND BIOGRAPHY

66. Abe Lincoln: The Boy Who Loved Books - Kay Winters (P)
We also love biographies and information books. This is a great introduction to our 16th president.

67. Bard of Avon: The Story of William Shakespeare - Diane Stanley (P)
Though it's a picture book, it's one of many on our shelves meant for older children. In fact, I read it to my government school high school students when introducing our Shakespeare units on Romeo and Juliet and Julius Caesar. It will give your children a framework of understanding about an author from whom you'll likely want them to read in later years.

68. The Boy on Fairfield Street - Kathleen Krull (P)
A very well-done picture book biography of Dr. Seuss

69. Childhood of Famous Americans books (C)
We have at least half a dozen of these titles, which describe the formative years of well-known Americans. I highly recommend them as a way in which to engage children in biography and American history.

70. Count Your Way through... books - Jim Haskins (P)
Each of these books focuses on a particular country, providing interesting facts about 10 different areas of life and culture. As an added bonus, you and your child can try your hand at counting to 10 in each country's main language.

71. George Washington's Breakfast - Jean Fritz (P)
After we first read this book, we made what Washington actually ate for breakfast. You'll have to read it to discover what that was!

72. George Washington's Mother - Jean Fritz (C)
This is a hilarious book that, nonetheless, provides true information about Washington's mother and childhood.

73. Getting to Know the World's Greatest Artists books - Mike Venezia (P)
We have a bunch of these. Each one provides a child-appropriate biography of a famous artist and keeps a child's attention through the inclusion of hilarious, relevant cartoons.

74. Getting to Know the World's Greatest Composers books - Mike Venezia (P)
See #73, above.

75. Getting to Know the U.S. Presidents books - Mike Venezia (P)
Ibid

76. I Can Read history books (C)
We have dozens of these titles as well - on everything from the "Boston Coffee Party" (did you know there was such a thing?) to the Pony Express to The Great Depression. It's a series that makes history accessible to elementary-aged children.

77. Little House on the Prairie and others in the series - Laura Ingalls Wilder (C)
As with the Narnia books, one cannot list great children's literature without including Laura Ingalls Wilder. We own them all and read them all, including On the Banks of Plum Creek, which we read while we were on the "Laura Ingalls Tour" through Minnesota and into South Dakota.

78. A Picture Book of... books - David Adler (P)
As I mentioned earlier, David Adler is a prolific writer of children's books - and does an amazing job. This series includes biographies of famous Americans (i.e., A Picture Book of Helen Keller and A Picture Book of Thomas Edison).

79. The Pilgrims of Plimoth - Marcia Sewall (P)
We have several books about the Pilgrims and the first Thanksgiving - and have checked out many more from the library over the years. This one is good for older kids and is interesting because it contains actual quotes from some of the Pilgrims' journals.

80. Squanto and the Miracle of Thanksgiving - Eric Metaxas (P)
I never learned about Squanto as a child - back then, we merely learned that the Indians helped the Pilgrims without learning any details - but this book (geared for older children) is one of several great ones I've read in recent years that fills in those blanks.

81. Step into Reading history books (C)
These are very similar to the I Can Read series and are equally as good.

82. The Story of Ruby Bridges - Robert Coles (P)
A picture book version of the true story of Ruby Bridges, one of the first children to attend newly-integrated schools in the South during the Civil Rights movement

83. Young Patriots Series books (C)
This is similar to - but easier than - the Childhood of Famous Americans series.

84. Young Princesses Around the World books (C)
We have books about Cleopatra, Queen Isabel of Spain, and Queen Elizabeth I of England. They tell of the women's childhoods, providing perfect supplementation for world history studies.


SCIENCE

85. All Aboard Science Readers series (C)
My older daughter, in particular, loved science books. These gave her independent access to a lot of concepts, especially about animals.

86. Backyard Books "Are You a ...?" series - Judy Allen (P)
This is a clever series in which the author teaches about insect anatomy and physiology by placing the reader in the role of the bug in question.

87. Bobbie Kalman books (P)
  • habitat series (The Antarctic Habitat, The Arctic Habitat, Backyard Habitats, A Desert Habitat, A Forest Habitat, A Grassland Habitat, A Rainforest Habitat, A Savanna Habitat, Underground Habitats, Water Habitats, A Wetland Habitat)
  • The Science of Living Things: What Is the Animal Kingdom?
  • The Science of Living Things: What Is a Living Thing?
  • The Science of Living Things: What Is a Plant?
I discovered Kalman in my quest for age-appropriate material about habitats and ecology. She presents a lot of useful information in accessible ways and includes beautiful photography to illustrate her points.

88. Let's-Read-and-Find-Out Science series (P)
These are probably the best-ever science books for elementary-aged children! Written about almost any conceivable scientific concept, they make sometimes complicated material accessible and enjoyable. We own dozens, and I think they're better than almost any science textbook up until at least the age of 10.

89. The Magic School Bus books - Joanna Cole (P)
I find these books overly "busy" - they contain lots of "sidebars" in addition to the main storylines - but my girls enjoyed them and gleaned a lot of science from them.

90. Stellaluna - Janell Cannon (P)
One of our favorite books ever, we even had a little stuffed animal version of Stellaluna, the protagonist! This is another in which learning is cleverly disguised within a good story, this time about a fruit bat who is separated from her mother.

91. Sunflower House - Eve Bunting (P)
A fun little story that will teach your children some botany - but be prepared for them to beg you for their own sunflower house

92. A Tree Is Nice - Janice M. Udry (P)
This is another oldie but goodie - definitely for the younger set, but sweet and instructive.


CHRISTIAN

93. 3 in 1: A Picture of God - Joanne Marxhausen (P)
Ever wonder how to explain the very abstract concept of the The Trinity to a concrete-thinking elementary-aged child? This book does a great job of it using an apple as the object lesson.

94. Angela and the Baby Jesus - Frank McCourt (P)
The true story of author McCourt's mother's encounter with the Baby Jesus statue in her Irish church

95. Easter in the Garden - Pamela Kennedy (P)
One of the best-written and most beautifully illustrated picture books about the Easter story we've read

96. Egermeier's Bible Story Book - Elsie E. Egermeier (C)
This was our read-aloud story Bible for several years, and it is a gem! I was thrilled with the depth and breadth of biblical knowledge this book gave to my daughters. And when we finished, we moved on to another excellent adaptation, The Child's Story Bible by Catherine Vos. 

97. God Gave Us... books - Lisa T. Bergren (P)
Bergren has written several of these delightful books - God Gave Us You, God Gave Us Two, God Gave Us Heaven, and God Gave Us Christmas - each one a celebration of family members' love each other and for God as their Creator.

98. Mad Maddie Maxwell - Stacie K.B. Maslyn (P)
This delightful book tells the story of Maddie, who overreacts and makes assumptions about her siblings but then is helped through the situation by a kind older sister.

99. Miss Fannie's Hat - Jan Karon (P)
Bring out the tissue for this one, too! It is a simple but profound story of an old woman and her hat collection. You must get this book!

100. My Birthday, Jesus' Birthday - Holly Davis (P)
This sweet book explains the Christmas story by comparing the events leading up to and just after Jesus' birth to corresponding events in a modern child's life. It helps make the biblical concepts accessible to children.

******

So there you have it - my 100 (or so) favorite kids' books! I know I've left out a lot of good ones - even from our own home library, let alone others we've only borrowed or about which we don't even know. But I think having "too many" quality children's books is a great problem to have!

In closing, I feel compelled to note that, sadly, a good many children's literature publishers have chosen to correlate to common core. "Correlation" doesn't mean book content was changed, but it does mean the publisher endorses common core and may have also written "common core correlation guides," typically used by classroom teachers. Because I do not want to send a message that I support common core, I've taken to buying my literature used - I can get new and almost-new books for great prices - so that the original publishers do not make profit from me. And I also purpose to buy editions published before 2010 if at all possible to avoid any potential common core-related content changes. I personally find it very irksome that even literature is not "safe" from common core, but that's an inescapable reality.

December 15, 2018

BBC Book List

A friend of mine once shared an interesting note on her Facebook page: a list of 100 books the BBC (British Broadcasting Corporation) deems so "important" that the question on the note was, "How many of these have you read?" My bookworm mother-in-law reported reading or seeing movie versions of 71 and another friend - a brilliant young lady who's been home-educated from the beginning and may very well become a journalist and writer in her adult life - had already read 48...at the tender age of 17!

I don't know how the BBC came up with the list or why it thinks of itself as an arbiter of good taste in literature (maybe just because it's British?!), but it's interesting nonetheless. I actually don't recommend forcing kids to read particular titles - instead, I promote a child-directed Readers' Workshop approach - and I would not have included at least a few of the titles - specifically, the Harry Potter series, The DaVinci Code, and Bridget Jones's Diary - because, for one thing, there's no way to really know if these modern popular works will stand the test of time in terms of classic or even noteworthy literature. And I would definitely have included others instead - Oscar Wilde's The Picture of Dorian Gray comes to mind as one example - but I think the list might be instructive (though not proscriptive) for my fellow home-educating moms as we consider what we may want to suggest - not mandate - that our children read before high school graduation. In addition, we may want to think about adding some of these titles to our own reading lists; after all, all of life is learning, and we want to model that behavior for our children!

Just for fun, I've underlined the titles I've already read and have put an asterisk in front of those I'm adding to my reading list. And, of course, I could not resist some editorial comments!

1. Pride and Prejudice – Jane Austen
I tried to get into this...but I really just wanted to ring the protagonists' necks and scream, "Get a backbone!"

2. The Lord of the Rings – J.R.R. Tolkien
I feel I should want to read this, but I don't like the fantasy genre so, in all honesty, I may never get around to it. However, I did watch (and enjoy) the movie series and, because Tolkien was a Christian, I've encouraged my girls to consider it.

* 3. Jane Eyre – Charlotte Brönte
I am afraid this may remind me of Austen and, thus, cause me to want to run screaming from my room. But I should give it a fair shot anyway - just to say I have. And perhaps I'll be pleasantly surprised.

4. Harry Potter series – J.K. Rowling
I have too many concerns about these books to get into here. Suffice it to say, I'm not interested. To the extent my girls like the genre, I encourage Tolkien and C.S. Lewis, among others, instead.

5. To Kill a Mockingbird – Harper Lee
Wow! I didn't read this until a few years ago, but I now consider it one of my all-time favorites! The sequel Ms. Lee actually wrote prior to Mockingbird and did not want to publish is not nearly as good, though. 

* 6. The Bible
In my mind, of course, this should be #1 because it is my guide for life and faith. Unfortunately, I haven't always been as committed to reading it (daily) as I should have been, but reading it through - even annually - is always a goal. It's God's Word and is, thus, living and active - so it speaks anew with each fresh reading. I believe it's essential reading for people of other-than-Christian faiths, too, since so many other books contain biblical allusions.

7. Wuthering Heights – Emily Brönte

8. Nineteen Eighty Four – George Orwell
I read this in high school. Given our current political climate, I should probably read it again.

9. His Dark Materials – Philip Pullman

10. Great Expectations – Charles Dickens

11. Little Women – Louisa M. Alcott
I read this several times in middle and high school. Each time I did so, I checked it out over Christmas vacation and spent the week buried in it.

12. Tess of the D’Urbervilles – Thomas Hardy
This book is monumentally tragic but is worth the read anyway.

13. Catch 22 – Joseph Heller

* 14. Complete Works of Shakespeare
Okay, I haven't read them all. Has anyone, really? All the plays and all the sonnets? Other than Ph.D.s in English literature, I highly doubt it. But I am always game for more Shakespeare. I was afraid of him until I returned to college in my mid-twenties; now I love him!

15. Rebecca – Daphne du Maurier

16. The Hobbit – J.R.R. Tolkien
See # 2, above.

17. Birdsong – Sebastian Faulks

18. Catcher in the Rye – J.D. Salinger

19. The Time Traveller’s Wife – Audrey Niffenegger

20. Middlemarch – George Eliot
This is one of my all-time favorite books - all 800+ pages of it!

* 21. Gone With The Wind – Margaret Mitchell
I've seen the movie, but not read the book. I wonder if the two are substantially different.

22. The Great Gatsby – F. Scott Fitzgerald
I did not like this, but I think that's because I disliked the characters more than Gatsby's actual story or writing style. It's hard to like a book whose characters you want to shake!

23. Bleak House – Charles Dickens

24. War and Peace – Leo Tolstoy
I love several of Tolstoy's short stories and really wanted to say I'd read War and Peace! But, as is the complaint of so many, I could not keep up with the multiple names and nicknames assigned to each of the multiple characters. I may try again some day, but I'm not especially motivated to do so any time soon.

25. The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy – Douglas Adams

26. Brideshead Revisited – Evelyn Waugh

* 27. Crime and Punishment – Fyodor Dostoyevsky
Dostoyevsky is on my very short list of "bucket list" must-read authors!

28. Grapes of Wrath – John Steinbeck
This is another of my favorites, both because I love the book itself and because it holds special memories for me. I performed a high school forensics declamation that took me all the way to the state competition using an excerpt from this. I wonder if I could still nail the accents?

29. Alice in Wonderland – Lewis Carroll

30. The Wind in the Willows – Kenneth Grahame

31. Anna Karenina – Leo Tolstoy
See #24, above.

32. David Copperfield – Charles Dickens

33. Chronicles of Narnia – C.S. Lewis
My husband read the entire series to our daughters.

34. Emma – Jane Austen
See #1, above.

35. Persuasion – Jane Austen
Why does the BBC love Austen so much?!

36. The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe – C.S. Lewis
I don't know why this is listed separately from #33. However, though I haven't read the whole series, I have read this one. As I said, I'm not a fan of the fantasy genre, but I enjoy the Christian allegory here so that makes it manageable, especially in reading it to my children.

37. The Kite Runner – Khaled Hosseini
My mother-in-law tells my husband and me that we should read this. 

38. Captain Corelli’s Mandolin – Louis de Berniere

39. Memoirs of a Geisha – Arthur Golden

40. Winnie the Pooh – A.A. Milne
I have, of course, read some of this, but I'm not sure I've ever read the whole thing.

41. Animal Farm – George Orwell
See #8, above.

42. The Da Vinci Code – Dan Brown
Why is this on the list? Harry Potter I can maybe understand, but this? It will be completely forgotten in short order.

43. One Hundred Years of Solitude – Gabriel Garcia Marquez

44. A Prayer for Owen Meaney – John Irving
I read another of his book's, The World According to Garp, years ago. That was more than enough Irving for me.

45. The Woman in White – Wilkie Collins

* 46. Anne of Green Gables – L.M. Montgomery
My girls, my mother-in-law, and I recently watched the PBS series from the 1980s, and were so delighted that I bought the entire series to read, too.

47. Far From the Madding Crowd – Thomas Hardy

48. The Handmaid’s Tale – Margaret Atwood

49. Lord of the Flies – William Golding
This book tragically illustrates the goals of institutional schooling.

50. Atonement – Ian McEwan

51. Life of Pi – Yann Martel

52. Dune – Frank Herbert
One of my best friends in high school was mesmerized by this book. At times, I wanted to be just like her, but the style just doesn't interest me.

53. Cold Comfort Farm – Stella Gibbons

54. Sense and Sensibility – Jane Austen
Can we please be done with Ms. Austen?!

55. A Suitable Boy – Vikram Seth

56. The Shadow of the Wind – Carlos Ruiz Zafon

* 57. A Tale Of Two Cities – Charles Dickens

* 58. Brave New World – Aldous Huxley

59. The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time – Mark Haddon

60. Love In The Time Of Cholera – Gabriel Garcia Marquez
Let's just say I was not impressed.

61. Of Mice and Men – John Steinbeck
I think Grapes of Wrath is better, but I also think any Steinbeck is worth reading.

62. Lolita – Vladimir Nabokov

63. The Secret History – Donna Tartt

64. The Lovely Bones – Alice Sebold

65. Count of Monte Cristo – Alexandre Dumas

66. On The Road – Jack Kerouac

67. Jude the Obscure – Thomas Hardy

68. Bridget Jones’s Diary – Helen Fielding
Really? This is supposed to be important literature?

69. Midnight’s Children – Salman Rushdie

70. Moby Dick – Herman Melville
If Middlemarch is the blessing of 800-page literature, this is the curse. Ugh!

71. Oliver Twist – Charles Dickens

72. Dracula – Bram Stoker

73. The Secret Garden – Frances Hodgson Burnett
My daughters have read this with my husband, and it's a favorite.

74. Notes From a Small Island – Bill Bryson

75. Ulysses – James Joyce
I'm not sure, but I think this might belong on the shelf next to Moby Dick...

76. The Bell Jar – Sylvia Plath

77. Swallows and Amazons – Arthur Ransome
This was another read-aloud my husband did with our girls. They all rave about it.

78. Germinal – Emile Zola

79. Vanity Fair – William Makepeace Thackeray
I read this in college. Middlemarch was much better, but this was okay.

80. Possession – A.S. Byatt

81. A Christmas Carol – Charles Dickens

82. Cloud Atlas – David Mitchell

83. The Color Purple – Alice Walker
I know now that I don't agree with Ms. Walker about much, politically or culturally. But she is a gifted author, that's for sure.

84. The Remains of the Day – Kazuo Ishiguro

85. Madame Bovary – Gustave Flaubert

86. A Fine Balance – Rohinton Mistry

87. Charlotte’s Web – E.B. White
I actually never read this as a child - just for the first time with my daughters. I'm glad to see it on a list like this.

88. The Five People You Meet In Heaven – Mitch Albom

89. Adventures of Sherlock Holmes - Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

90. The Faraway Tree Collection – Enid Blyton

91. Heart of Darkness – Joseph Conrad
I remember thinking I wasn't sure at the time if I liked it or not. It's a hard read, emotionally.

92. The Little Prince - Antoine De Saint-Exupery
I had to read this in high school, as it was one of my English teacher's favorite books. She was my favorite teacher and a mentor so I wanted to adore it, too...but I could not stand it! I wonder if I would appreciate it more now?

93. The Wasp Factory – Iain Banks

94. Watership Down – Richard Adams

95. A Confederacy of Dunces – John Kennedy Toole

96. A Town Like Alice – Nevil Shute

97. The Three Musketeers – Alexandre Dumas

98. Hamlet – William Shakespeare
I don't know why this is listed separately from #14. My favorite Shakespeare plays are King Lear, Macbeth, and The Merchant of Venice, but this one comes in a close fourth.

99. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory – Roald Dahl
I've seen the movie, but not read the book.

* 100. Les Miserables – Victor Hugo
My girls performed selections from the musical version of this book for their homeschool choir, and we were able to see a professional production and . watch a couple of movie versions during the same year. Now I'm committed to reading the book as well.

What do you think? Is the list representative of truly great books? Which have you read? Which would you like to read? Where do you agree and disagree with my opinions?

*****
Photo Credit: Jeniee 

September 26, 2018

Stop Believing the Lie

If I had a dollar for all the pleas I've heard from young homeschool moms at their wits' end because their four-, five-, or six-year olds weren't yet reading, I'd be able to thoroughly fund my daughters' curriculum needs each year...and then some.

I see such entreaties almost daily, from moms desperate to figure out why their newly-minted five-year olds cannot grasp beginning phonics. They all believe that either their current phonics program might be inadequate or that their children must have learning disabilities.

And I always long to reach through the computer screen, grasp the mom by the shoulders, look her in the eye, and shout, "Put down the curriculum and stop believing the lie!"

That would be the lie of the institutional school system, which has our society now believing that formal 4K classes are an academic necessity (with the push for 3K and even 2K (!) already knocking at the door), that all children must accomplish the same cognitive tasks at the same time, and that every child must learn to read at the age of five (if not before) or be doomed to a life of illiteracy.

Yes, it's all a lie.

The truth of the matter is that each individual child has been created by God as a unique, one-of-a-kind miracle. Which means, to put it bluntly, that it's nothing short of immoral to expect all children to learn the same things at the same time, at the same pace, in the same way. And, besides that, it's unscientific! Yes, some children are developmentally ready to learn to read at five. Heck, some are ready at three or even two. But some perfectly healthy children are simply not ready until six or seven or even later in some cases. Thus, it's both foolish and wrong to expect all children to read by age five and to negatively label those who are simply wired to grasp the skill a little later.

Sadly (with the exception of some very dedicated individual teachers here and there), we cannot expect the institutional schools to really take individual needs into consideration. After all, the very nature of the system is to "standardize" its young clientele. But we can get past that lie in home education - and we owe it to our children (and the God who took such care in crafting each one uniquely) to do so.

Yes, some children actually do have learning difficulties that hinder their ability to learn to decode and comprehend fluently. However, it's unfair and patently ridiculous to make such a diagnosis in a five-year old. If a child shows no interest or demonstrates extremely limited progress by the age of eight, a more formal evaluation (ideally done by a professional in private practice, not someone associated with the government schools) is probably warranted. But in most cases, a child who has no interest or aptitude at age five will seem to "blossom overnight" a year or two later...if we keep the pressure off and accept each child's individuality.

Conversely, if we push before a child is ready, we won't make any progress, and we'll be extremely frustrated. Worse than that, we'll stress and frustrate the child for no good reason, which could set her up for a lifelong aversion to the very activity we felt compelled to push on her.

Most kids will require formal instruction in learning to read so, by all means, do your research and choose a solid, phonics-based approach. Have it on hand. And then just wait...and watch. If your child is destined to be an early reader, he'll likely start picking things up "by osmosis," at which point you can pull out your materials and give them a try. Otherwise, feel free to try your chosen program after your child turns five (or even later) - there is no need to even attempt it before then unless he initiates! - and see how it goes. If he takes to it, keep going. But, if there is any resistance or difficulty, simply put it away for a few months. And then wait...and watch some more. Eventually, you will see obvious readiness signs - he'll begin asking what words say, he'll "read" the text of books he's memorized, he'll directly ask you to teach him to read - and/or he'll suddenly take to the phonics book in a way he never did before. And then you'll know he's ready.

By all means, create a literacy-friendly environment for your children: surround them with books to explore; introduce them to letters and sounds in fun, informal ways; and (most importantly) read, read, read to them (multiple times every day from birth on). But, beyond that, the key is to simply stop believing the lie and go forward from there.

*****
Photo Credit: Janeice Bull 

September 23, 2018

Reading is the Key

"A child who reads will be an adult who thinks."

Whoever first said these words uttered one of the greatest educational truths ever spoken.

The fact is that, if a person can read well, he can learn about nearly anything else in the world, as needed. There are, of course, other wonderful ways to learn - i.e., learning by doing (hands-on, project-based activities) and learning by direct experience (i.e., travel). But most of us won't travel as extensively as we'd perhaps like to and even many hands-on projects require some reading as well. Thus, being able to read well enough to enjoy doing so is an educational hallmark.

As I've pondered this concept over the years - while concurrently seeing myriad homeschool moms fret over what subjects to cover with their kids and even thinking about that for my own children - I've come to a strong conviction about the foundation of our home education endeavors: If my kids can read well (which means that they'll be "thinkers" by default), communicate clearly (orally and in writing), and competently manage computational math (not necessarily "higher math," depending on the child), all the rest is gravy.

In other words, those "basic" skills (the old-fashioned "3-Rs") really do provide the foundation for all other learning. It's not that we shouldn't address other content areas like history, science, the arts, etc. In fact, I believe we do well to find engaging ways to expose our kids to an overview of those various "subjects" before they reach adolescence in order to build mental "hooks" on which they can hang all that they'll learn through the rest of their lives. And then in adolescence, we should endeavor to maximize the development of the unique gifts and abilities we begin to see in each child, diligently working through a wholly customized plan for each one (i.e., there should be no such thing as a "standardized curriculum" - where every young person has to learn all the same content) in order to prepare them all to confidently launch into adulthood. But when it comes right down to it, once a child has learned to read well - or, if true reading disabilities exist, to employ very helpful technology such as audiobooks - his educational toolbox is ready to tackle any cognitive endeavor he seeks to pursue for the rest of his life.

In reality, if we give our kids "only" the 3Rs - a rock-solid foundation in readin', (w)ritin' and 'rithmetic! - and then commit to a fully personalized plan for other content areas (purposing to eliminate every vestige of "filler," material we think kids should learn only because "everyone does," and busywork), we have given our kids everything they truly need to engage well in any life endeavor each might choose to pursue.

Nurture kids into becoming strong readers - when the time is right for each one! - and everything else in the world will be open to them.

September 20, 2018

My Biggest Mistake as a Homeschool Mom

I often say we've been homeschooling "from the beginning" - meaning from the moment each of my children was born - because I know that all of life is learning. Thus, I was as much a homeschool mom when my girls were toddlers as I was when they were 10 and 11...and as I am now that they're teens. The content changes over time, but it's all learning in an independent, home-based environment directed by me. Thus, it's all homeschooling.

That said, my state mandates that compulsory "school" attendance begin the year a child turns six before September 1. So, by that definition, I've been an "official homeschooler" since I filed my first legally-required annual notification in the fall of 2007.

My biggest mistake as a homeschool mom, though, began in May, 2006, stemming from my propensity to be an overachiever. Well, that and my former inclination toward people-pleasing.

I'd done well with not pushing early academics when the girls were preschoolers. I did explore different preschool "curriculum" programs, but not because I felt I had to do anything formal; instead, I just wanted to find some age-appropriate activities to guide me - a former middle and high school teacher who knew little about education for younger kids - and to lend a bit of structure to our days. In truth, though, preschool around here mainly consisted of lots of read-alouds, continual discussion about what we read and saw, some theme-based arts and crafts, occasional outings, and lots of time to play with toys - both of the official "educational" variety (i.e., puzzles and shape sorters) and also good ol' "regular" toys like Barbies and Little People.

But then my older daughter turned five, and I lost my mind.

You see, though I didn't legally need to do anything formal for more than a year, I of course knew that many kids start "kindergarten" when they turn five. And I realize now, in hindsight, that I was nervous about what people would say if my kids appeared to be "behind" their same-aged peers. Add to that my knowledge that the kids in many local homeschool families I respected were "advanced" and my own academic background - I was shoved into kindergarten when I was still four and ended up as valedictorian of my high school class and a magna cum laude college graduate - and it's no wonder I fell into the trap.

Yes, I pushed...an admission which still drives me to tears of deep regret more than 10 years later.

Thankfully, I had enough wherewithal to avoid the most overly rigorous formal kindergarten programs - and the curriculum I did choose included some good elements appropriate for four- and five-year olds: gentle, hands-on math instruction...some engaging history stories...fun Bible- and history-themed songs complete with hand motions and other actions...regular art projects. And - though I now realize how wholly unnecessary it was at that point - both of my daughters actually enjoyed and could manage the handwriting program I chose.

But then there was phonics. And, of course, I knew that the ability to read well is the crux of everything when it comes to education, whether we're talking literature, chemistry, or Bible study. So I purchased an expensive, systematic program and set out to get both girls reading as soon as possible.

Set aside for a moment that I thought I needed to formally teach phonics to a four-year old; that's a story for a different time, but not my biggest mistake because I figured out my error with my younger daughter pretty quickly and backed off with her. No, my biggest mistake was continuing to push my older girl with phonics even after I got a clue with the younger...simply because she was five, and that's what I was "supposed to do."

Never mind what would have been best for my child: at minimum, radically modifying how I used the pricey program or, at best, setting it (and all formal phonics instruction) aside for a time while I researched materials better suited to her learning style and watched her for true readiness. Nope, I had a job to do - a job I thought required me to try making my child fit into the lesson plans regardless of her actual, demonstrated readiness and learning needs.

The time we spent on reading lessons was dreadful. My sweet girl struggled; she tried so hard, but she couldn't recall the individual phonemes the way the program said she was "supposed to," and she really got stuck on consonant blends. In response, I tensed up...every.single.day. And I yelled at her. Yes, I yelled at my little girl simply because remembering the connections between letters and sounds was tricky for her at that time, using that method.

I'm so ashamed to admit that. But I do it with the hope that my transparency will wake up even just one new homeschool mom who thinks right now that the curriculum trumps her child's real needs. And I won't mince words: It is just a bald-faced lie that you "must" start formal instruction of any particular content area at a certain age just because "everyone else is doing it," or that you "must" go at a certain pace so the child masters a set amount of content on anyone else's timetable. The institutional schools do what they do, but that doesn't make it right...and it most certainly doesn't mean that we who home-educate need to follow suit. Instead, we need to be wise enough to figure out the actual readiness level of each of our children and courageous enough to use that knowledge as our guiding force in planning an individualized course of formal academics.

God was incredibly gracious to this foolish homeschool mom. First and foremost, He protected my daughter's heart from her momma's stressed-out scolding so that - miraculously - she still loves me, respects me, and wants to learn from and with me. I don't deserve any of that. Second, He woke me up to the error of my ways - to my sin against my daughter - before I'd done too much damage to her sense of competence. And, finally, He enabled her to learn to read and gave her a joy for it despite all the pressure I put on her. By all rights, she should either hate reading or feel "paralyzed" by the thought of it...but, instead, she's a bookworm, and her skills are solid.

However, just because we got "lucky" doesn't justify what I did. It did work out in the end, but it was despite what I did, not because of it. My daughter's road to becoming a competent, confident reader was much bumpier than it needed to be. And the fact remains that my pushing could have done serious, serious damage to her soul and to our relationship - not to mention to her desire and ability to learn. That happens every single day in institutional schools -  where children are grouped with same-aged peers regardless of each one's actual readiness and are expected to perform according to the cookie-cutter model of the system - and homeschools are not immune to it.

So I implore you, new homeschool mom, to learn from my mistake. Some children are actually ready to learn to read at an early age - we've probably all heard of a three-year old who picked up a copy of The Boxcar Children and devoured it in a day - but that's not the norm and should not be our standard. Neither should we assume that kids need to read by age five simply because the institutional schools continue to promote "academic pushdown" (i.e., teaching what was once considered first grade material in kindergarten...or even 4K). There is an agenda behind that practice, and it has nothing to do with what's actually best for kids. If you don't believe me, maybe this brilliant video produced by Yale University's Gesell Institute of Human Development will convince you.

I'm not saying that five-year olds should not learn anything about phonics - or other formal academic content. I am saying, though, that we homeschool moms shouldn't fall prey to the lie that there is one right timetable or one correct method for every child - when it comes to learning to read or anything else. And I am saying that, no matter the pressure we get from family, friends, and educational "experts" in the government schools or the "performance anxiety" we feel within ourselves, "better late than early" and allowing our young children to primarily learn through a wide variety of play activities is best in most cases. The bottom line is that we have a responsibility to really know each of our children - in terms of readiness and preferred learning style - and to do what's right for each one on an individual basis instead of caving to fear and outside pressure.


Trust me on that one so you don't have my regrets down the road.

*****
A version of this article appeared in the Fall 2018 edition of Learning Tangent Magazine.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...